Bishop Chatard Wall of Fame Recipients
| Name | Year | Parish | Sport(s) | Award |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Marietta, Tony | 1964 | Football | All-City | |
| Hughes, Tim | 1965 | Football | All Capitol District Conference; Other-Kiwanis Club Football MVP Award | |
| Fritz, Al | 1966 | Football | All-City, All-District | |
| Akin, Tim | 1967 | CTK | Football | All Capitol District Conference |
| Shircliff, Wayne | 1967 | Golf | City medalist, Cap. Dist. Conf. Medalist, Sect. Medalist, Reg. Medalist | |
| Veza, Dan | 1967 | Wrestling | Cap. District Champion, All-City | |
| Christenberry, Tom | 1968 | Baseball | All-City | |
| Gresk, Paul | 1968 | Football | All-City, Indiana All-star | |
| Gruesser, John | 1968 | Football | All-City | |
| Kinghorn, David | 1968 | Football | All-City | |
| Proffitt, Dick | 1968 | SJA | Football | All-City, All State, Indiana All-star |
| Queisser, Harold | 1968 | Football, Baseball | All-cap. District, All-City | |
| Christenberry, Mike | 1969 | Baseball | 3rd base All-City | |
| Fields, Terry | 1969 | Baseball | All-City | |
| Ford, Joe | 1969 | SJA | Golf | All City 1968 & 69 |
| Hennessey, Bud | 1969 | SJA | Baseball | All-City |
| McDonough, Mark | 1969 | Football | All-City, All-State, Catholic All-american | |
| Otto, Ken | 1969 | Baseball | All-City | |
| Pratt, Jim | 1969 | SPX | Baseball | All-City |
| Pratt, Jim | 1969 | SPX | Baskeball, Football, Baseball | All- Setional, All-Capital District, End, – All-City, All-State, Catholic All-American |
| Russell, Rory | 1969 | Football | H.B. – All-City | |
| Veza, John | 1969 | Football | All City & All State 1968 & 69; Catholic All American 1969 | |
| Dowd, Joe | 1970 | Football | F.B. – Kicker – All-City | |
| McFarren, Dan | 1970 | Wrestling | 128 LBS. – City Champion, Sectional Champion, Regional Champion, State Champion | |
| McFarren, Dave | 1970 | Wrestling | City Champion | |
| Poehlien, Greg | 1970 | Football | Tackle – All – City | |
| Rochford, Jim | 1970 | Football | Guard (FB) – All – City | |
| Halvorson, Mark | 1971 | Wrestling | 98 LBS. – City Champion, Sectional Champion | |
| Homola, Ken | 1971 | Football, Basketball | End – All-City, All-State, Forward – All-Sectional | |
| Lynch, Bill | 1971 | CTK | Basketball, Football, Track | Guard – All- Sectional, Q.B. – All-City All-State, Indiana All-Star |
| O’Brian, Tim | 1971 | SJA | Football, Wrestling | WR City Champion, FB All-City |
| Petit, Van | 1971 | SJA | Wrestling | 126 lbs. – City Champion |
| Robertson, Bill | 1971 | Football | Center – All-City | |
| Scheidler, John | 1971 | AND | Football | End – All-City, Indiana All-Star |
| Williams, Jack | 1971 | Wrestling | 138 LBS. – Sectional Champion, Regional Champion | |
| Dum, Gary | 1972 | Wrestling | 138 LBS. – City Champion, Sectional Champion | |
| Hayes Joe | 1972 | Baseball | All-City | |
| Morrow, Steve | 1972 | Baseball | All-City | |
| Queisser, Tim | 1972 | SJA | Football | HB. – All-City |
| Wyler, Dave | 1972 | Football | Defensive End – All-City | |
| Breiner, Jeff | 1973 | Football | All-City | |
| Johnson, Dan | 1973 | Wrestling, Football | FB-All City & All State 1972; WR-City, Sectional, Regional & STATE Champion 1973 | |
| KuykendAll, Steve | 1973 | LAW | Baseball | All-City |
| Latty, Bob | 1973 | Baseball | All-City | |
| Malone, Duane | 1973 | Football | All-City | |
| Milam, Greg | 1973 | Football | All-City, All-State | |
| Myers, Ed | 1973 | Baseball | All-City | |
| Pratt, Dave | 1973 | SPX | Baseball | All-City |
| Welch, Vince | 1973 | SJA | Wrestling | 145lbs. City Champion |
| Commiskey, Pat | 1974 | MATT | Football | L.B. – All-City |
| Conolty, Kevin | 1974 | Football | All-City, All-State, Indiana All-Star | |
| Dum, Steve | 1974 | Wrestling | Sectional Champion, regional Champion, City Champion, State Champion | |
| Jackson, John | 1974 | Baseball, Football | All-City 2nd base, All-City Tail Back | |
| Jackson, Steve | 1974 | Baseball | 3rd Base – All-City | |
| Jansen, Greg | 1974 | NC | Basketball | All-City |
| Lux, Mark | 1974 | CTK | Wrestling | Sectional Champion |
| Mercuri, Mike | 1974 | Football | Safety – All-City | |
| Petit, Bruce | 1974 | SJA | Wrestling | 119 LBS. – City Champion, Sectional, Champion, 3rd in State- State Champion |
| Scheidler, Dave | 1974 | AND | Football, Wrestling | D.E. All-City, All-State, 167 LBS. – Sectional and Regional Champion |
| Spanton, Rich | 1974 | NC | Baseball | Pitcher – All-City |
| Tucker, James | 1974 | RITA | Basketball | All-Sectional, All-City |
| Buhler, Chris | 1975 | LAW | Track | 800YD. Run – All-time Marion County Record, City Champion, Sectional Champion, Tri-State meet State 4th |
| Catton, Mark | 1975 | SPX | Baseball | All-City |
| Early, Pat | 1975 | Baseball | R.F. – All-City | |
| Evenson, Mark | 1975 | Baseball | All-City | |
| Klee, Bob | 1975 | CTK | Wrestling | 185 LBS. – City Champion, Sectional Champion |
| Parrish, Kevin | 1975 | Baseball | All-City, All-State | |
| Quinn, Mark | 1975 | SPX | Football | Tackle – All – City, All-State, Indiana All-Star |
| Roller, Howard | 1975 | Baseball | D.H. – All-City | |
| Scheidler, Bill | 1975 | AND | Football | L.B. – All-State, All-City |
| Dessauer, Dave | 1976 | CTK | Wrestling | City Champion, Sectional Champion, Regional Champion, Semi-State Champion |
| Dury, John | 1976 | IHM | Baseball | All-City |
| Fobes, Jeff | 1976 | Football | All-City | |
| Foley, Steve | 1976 | SJA | Wrestling | Sectional Champion |
| Ford, Mike | 1976 | SJA | Basketball | All-Sectional |
| Goebel, Joe | 1976 | SPX | Cross Country | City Champion |
| Homola, Greg | 1976 | Football | All-City | |
| Marks, Bob | 1976 | SPX | Football, Baseball | All-City, All-State, All-City |
| McGlacken, Geoff | 1976 | LAW | Wrestling | HWT.- Sectional Champion, Regional Champion, semi-st. Champion |
| McKay, John | 1976 | Wrestling | Sectional Champion | |
| Primavera, Tom | 1976 | SPX | Baseball | All City |
| Wilkes, Randy | 1976 | STA | Basketball | All-Sectional |
| Buckheit, Mark | 1977 | Football | All-City | |
| Dattilo, Angelo | 1977 | Football | All-City | |
| Getz, C.J. | 1977 | CTK | Wrestling | Sectional Champion, Regional Champion |
| Hackman, Steve | 1977 | SPX | Track | City Champion, Sectional Champion, Regional Champion, 2nd in State, Winner in American meet of Champions |
| Kowich, Bob | 1977 | Basketball | All-Sectional, All-City | |
| Leonard, Joe | 1977 | Basketball | All-City | |
| Tekulve, Keith | 1977 | Football | All-City | |
| Collignon, Tom | 1978 | SPX | Football | All-City football |
| Farney, Tim | 1978 | SPX | Football | All-City |
| Howard, Andy | 1978 | SPX | Football | All-City |
| Jansen, Joe | 1978 | Football | Indiana All-Star | |
| Lux, Mike | 1978 | CTK | Wrestling | City Champion |
| Rodich, Roger | 1978 | Football | All City | |
| Conger, Ron | 1979 | Track | Polevault – City Champion | |
| Deschryver, Bob | 1979 | Football | All-City | |
| Kenney, Vince | 1979 | MATT | Football | All City, All State, Indianapolis All-star |
| Klug, Greg | 1979 | SPX | Football | All-City |
| Sylvester, Bill | 1979 | STA | Football | All-City |
| Woolen, Kelly | 1979 | CTK | Volleyball, Basketball, Track | All-City, All-metro; City Athlete of the Year |
| Hunsicker, Bill | 1980 | Football | Defensive Halfback – All-City | |
| Thompson, Aaron | 1980 | SJA | Basketball | All-City, All-Sectional |
| Thompson, Daron | 1980 | SJA | Basketball | All-City, All-Sectional |
| Anderson, William | 1981 | Basketball | All-City, All-Sectional, All-Regional | |
| Arnold, Kevin | 1981 | Basketball | All-City, All-City Tourney All-Sectional, All-Regional | |
| Boso, Cap | 1981 | MATT | Football, Baseball | Tight End – All-City, Catcher – All-City |
| Dietrick, P.J. | 1981 | SPX | Baseball | Shortstop – All-City |
| DuBois, Michelle | 1981 | SPX | Tennis | Doubles City Champion |
| Fagan, Kathy | 1981 | MATT | Tennis | All-City |
| Keating, Shawn | 1981 | IHM | Basketball, Football | All- Regional, Offensive Back – All-City |
| Labus, Ted | 1981 | Football | Split End – All-City-, All-State | |
| Meloy, Pat | 1981 | SPX | Baseball | Pitcher – All-City |
| Murphy, James | 1981 | Cross Country | City Champion, Sectional Champion, Regional Champion, Semi-State Champion, City Champion, Sectional, Regional, State Champion, All-State, All-American | |
| Obergfell, Dave | 1981 | Baseball | Outfield – All-City | |
| Sullivan, John | 1981 | CTK | Wrestling | Sectional Champion |
| Sylvester, Jill | 1981 | STA | Volleyball, Tennis | All-City volleyball, All-City tennis, #1 doubles City Champion |
| Valainis, Maris | 1981 | SJA | Golf | All-City |
| Van Camp, Peggy | 1981 | SPX | Track | Shotput – City Champion |
| Wojciehowski, Stan | 1981 | CTK | Golf | City Player of the Year |
| Ackermann, Lisa | 1982 | SPX | Volleyball | All-City |
| Cates, Tricia | 1982 | SPX | Tennis | All-City |
| DuBois, Jill | 1982 | SPX | Volleyball, Basketball | VB-All City 1980; BB-All City 1981 | Other-Academic All-State Basketball, Bishop Chatard Career Athlete Award (Tennis, Volleyball, and Basketball) |
| Dury, George | 1982 | IHM | Football | All-City, Indiana All-star |
| Early, Michelle | 1982 | Swimming | All-City, State Finalist | |
| Horr, Ross | 1982 | CTK | Wrestling | Sectional SemiState Champion State Finalist, Sectional Champion State Finalist |
| Jilbert, Bill | 1982 | MATT | Football | All-City |
| Sullivan, SAlly | 1982 | SPX | Volleyball | All-City |
| Valainis, Andy | 1982 | SJA | Golf | IHSAA State Champion, Current State 9 Hole Record Holder, (32 & Old Oakland) Indiana State Tourney All-City, Indianapolis City Long Drive Champion |
| Bailey, Delvin | 1983 | NC | Football | All-City, All-State |
| Barnes, Chris | 1983 | LAW | Football | All-City, Catholic All-State |
| Bremer, Mike | 1983 | LUKE | Golf | Sect. Medalist, City Medalist, All-City, Player of the year |
| Cannon, Gary | 1983 | AND | Basketball, Football | All-City, All-sect., All-reg., All-metro, Hon. Men All-State, hon. Men All-american, All-City, All-State |
| Carroll, Julie | 1983 | Tennis | City Champion | |
| Catton, Ed | 1983 | SPX | Golf | All-City |
| Heikkila, Tapio | 1983 | FOR | Football | Kicker- All-City |
| Klee, Marea | 1983 | LAW | Softball | All-City |
| Mascari, Jeff | 1983 | LAW | Wrestling | Sect. Champion |
| Masters, Rick | 1983 | NC | Football | All-City,All-City,All-State,All-Star |
| Newbold, Mark | 1983 | CTK | Football | All-City |
| Qualters, Carol | 1983 | SPX | Softball | All-City |
| Sylvester, Jody | 1983 | STA | Tennis, Volleyball | Tennis: City Champion, Volleyball: All-City |
| Walker, Anne | 1983 | SPX | Track | 800M- City Champion |
| Weaver, Susie | 1983 | STA | Tennis | City Champion |
| Boyd, Darrin | 1984 | LAW | Baseball | All City | Centerfield |
| Breunig, Brenda | 1984 | SPX | Softball | All-City |
| Dury, Anne | 1984 | IHM | Softball | All City 1983 & 84 |
| Fillenwarth, Jack | 1984 | LAW | Football | All-City |
| Franklin, Terry | 1984 | NC | Track | City Champ-LJ, 200 & 400R 1982-83-84; Sectional & Regional Champ-LJ 1984; Sectional Champ-200 1984; State Qualifier-LJ 1983; State 2nd Place-LJ & 200 1984; State 3rd Place-400R 1984; ALL AMERICAN-LJ & 200 1984 |
| Hackman, Dan | 1984 | SPX | Football, Track | FB-All City 1983 & 84, All State 1984; Track: City & Regional Champ-Discus 1984, City-Sectional-Regional Champ-Discus 1985, State Qualifier 1985 | Other-Catholic All-State |
| Harmon, Mike | 1984 | SPX | Baseball | All-City, north All-star |
| McCann, Matt | 1984 | LUKE | Baseball | All-City Pitcher |
| McKinney, Ken | 1984 | STA | Basketball | All-City, All-City tourney |
| O’Brien, Mary Beth | 1984 | LUKE | Volleyball, Tennis | All-City, #2 doubles City Champion |
| Quigley, Dan | 1984 | IHM | Track, Cross Country | XC-City Champ 1982 & 83, Sectional & Regional Champ 1983; Track: City Champ-1600 & 3200 1982-83-84, Sectional Champ-3200 1983 & 1600 1983 & 84, State Finalist-1600 & 3200 1983 & 84 |
| Sahm, John | 1984 | IHM | Football | All City 1983 & 84, All State 1984, Indiana All Star 1984 | Other-Catholic All-State, QB |
| Bill, Glenn | 1985 | CTK | Football | All-City, All-State, Indiana All-Star, Catholic All-State |
| Bremer, David | 1985 | LUKE | Golf | co-City Champion |
| Cottrell, Tim | 1985 | SJA | Basketball | All-City, All-Sectional, All-regional |
| Fagan, Kerry | 1985 | MATT | Volleyball, Tennis | All-City, #2 doubles tennis Champion |
| Finnell, Todd | 1985 | Football, Track | Football All-City, Track Long Jump, Sectional, Regional Champion and State Runner-up | |
| Kinghorn, Kirby | 1985 | SPX | Cross Country, Track | XC-City, Sectional, Regional Champ 1984, State Qualifier 1984; Track: City Champ-1600 & 3200 1985, Regional Champ-1600 1984, Sectional Champ-3200 1985, State Finalist-1600 1984, State Qualifier-3200 1985, State 3rd Place-1600 1985 |
| Murphy, Todd | 1985 | SPX | Baseball | All-City |
| O’Hara, Pat | 1985 | CTK | Football | All-City |
| Qualters, Mike | 1985 | SPX | Baseball | All-City, North All-star Team |
| Ackermann, Tom | 1986 | SPX | Baseball | All-City |
| Barnes, Vince | 1986 | LAW | Swimming | All-City |
| Coffee, Raphael | 1986 | Baseball | All-City | |
| Fisher, Troy | 1986 | Track | Long Jump Sectional Champion, | |
| Hodel, Kris | 1986 | Football | All-City, All-Metro, All-State | |
| Hofmeister, Emily | 1986 | Volleyball | All-City, All-Metro | |
| Hunnicut, Brian | 1986 | Football, Track | Lineman- All-City, All-State, Iniana All-Star, Catholic All-State, Track-Shotput Sectional Champion | |
| Ockomon, Jan | 1986 | Swimming | City Champion | |
| Orban, Chuck | 1986 | Football | All-City, All-Metro, All-State, All Catholic State, Sectional Champion | |
| Russell, Greg | 1986 | Soccer | All State | |
| Sullivan, Katie | 1986 | SPX | Volleyball | All-City, All-Metro |
| Ayers, Todd | 1987 | Cross Country | City Champion | |
| Brogan, Ted | 1987 | LAW | Golf | All City, Regional Champ/Medalist |
| Cottrell, Ricky | 1987 | SJA | Wrestling, Football | Defensive Back- All-City, Wrestling 155LBS.- City Champion, Section Champion, Regional Champion, State Finalist |
| Davis, Steve | 1987 | Basketball | Guard- All-Sectional, All-City | |
| Deiter, Marie | 1987 | SJA | Track | City Track Champion 1600 |
| Dury, Mary | 1987 | IHM | Softball | All-City |
| Guntz, Elaine | 1987 | IHM | Track | 800M- City Champion, Sectional Champion 3rd in State |
| Leighton, Sheila | 1987 | Softball | All-City | |
| Maxey, Chet | 1987 | Football, Wrestling, Track | Nosetackle- All-City, All- Metro, All-State, Wrestling Heavyweight -City Champion, Sectional Champion, Track- Discs- Sectional Champion | |
| Rutland, Rich | 1987 | Basketball | Guard- All-City | |
| Sahm, Mike | 1987 | IHM | Football | Catholic All-State |
| Shirmeyer, Pat | 1987 | LUKE | Track | City Champion, Sectional Champion |
| Smith, Joe | 1987 | Soccer | All-State | |
| Sochaki, Joe | 1987 | Soccer | All State | |
| Stober, Laura | 1987 | SPX | Volleyball | All-City, All-Metro |
| Trier, Joe | 1987 | CTK | Football | All-City, All-State U.P.I., All-Metro |
| Turner, Robbie | 1987 | Football, Basketball, Track | All-City, Catholic All-City, Catholic All-State-UPI, AP All-State, All American honorable mention, All-Sectional, All-City track, City Champion 400m relay, City Athlete of the year | |
| Walker, John | 1987 | Track | 100 meter City Champion, Sectional Champion, Regional Champion, State meet third, 200 Meter City Champion, Sectional Champion, Regional Champion, 400 Relay City Champion | |
| Wright, Heather | 1987 | SPX | Volleyball | All-City, All-Metro |
| Bonds, Marcel | 1988 | Basketball | All-Regional | |
| Brogan, Terry | 1988 | LAW | Golf | City Champ/Medalist-1985 & 87, All City 1988, State Finalist & All State 1988 |
| Cottman, Jeff | 1988 | Football, Track | All-City, Shot Put City Champion, State Finalist | |
| Davis, Giles | 1988 | Track | 400 Realy City Champion, Relay State Finalist, 3rd in State | |
| Feeney, Karen | 1988 | SPX | Volleyball | All-City |
| Harding, Deon | 1988 | Football, Track | All-City, North-South All Star, 400 Relay City Champion, Regional Champion, 3rd in State, City Champion Long Jump | |
| Jones, Sean | 1988 | Wrestling | Sectional Champioin 140 LBS., Semi-State Qualifier | |
| Jones, Steve | 1988 | Baseball | All-City | |
| Keating, Kiernan | 1988 | IHM | Football | All-City |
| Leone, Kevin | 1988 | SPX | Baseball | All-City 3rd base, All-City CenterField |
| Nester, Jeff | 1988 | SPX | Baseball | All-City |
| O’Brien, Matt | 1988 | LAW | Basketball | All-Sectional |
| Roney, Kris | 1988 | Track | IHSAA State Champion, 110 high hurdles City, Sectional, Regional Champion, 300 low hurdles City Champion, 400 relay City, Sectional, Regional Champion 3rd in State | |
| Yovanovich, Tim | 1988 | Football, Track | A.P. All-State, Discus State Finalist | |
| Andrews, Kent | 1989 | Basketball | All-City, All-Sectional, All-Regional | |
| Campbell, Aaron | 1989 | Golf | State Finals team, City Champion | |
| Davis, Yvette | 1989 | Track | City Champion – Shot Put & Discus | |
| Jones, Michelle | 1989 | Softball | All-City | |
| Kinghorn, Dan | 1989 | SPX | Track | 800M City Champion |
| O’Brien, Janeen | 1989 | LUKE | Tennis | City Champion #1 Doubles, #2 Doubles |
| O’Conner, Karen | 1989 | Volleyball | All-City | |
| Rhymes, Marcus | 1989 | Track | City runner-up, Sectional 3rd, City Champion, North Central Invite, Sectional Runner-up | |
| Ryan, Meg | 1989 | LAW | Tennis | City Champion #1 Doubles |
| Smuck, Jenny | 1989 | Volleyball | All-City | |
| Townsend, Richard | 1989 | Basketball | All-City, All-Sectional, All-regional | |
| Williams, Todd | 1989 | Basketball | All-City,All-Sectional | |
| Brelage, Brad | 1990 | Wrestling | 104 LBS. Sectional Champion, 112 LBS. Sectional Champion, Regional Champion, State Finalist, 119 LBS. City Champion, Sectional Champion, Regional Champion, State Finalist, City Swestler of the Year, Academic All-State, Career Record: 105-19-1 | |
| Clark, Quincey | 1990 | CTK | Football | All-City, All-State |
| Curtis, Kelli | 1990 | SPX | Softball | S.S. All-City |
| DeCosta, Sean | 1990 | Wrestling | 135 LBS. Sectional Champion | |
| Harmon, Nick | 1990 | SPX | Baseball | All-City 3rd Base |
| Kaplan, Mike | 1990 | Soccer | All-City, Academic All-State | |
| Lasley, Kenny | 1990 | SJA | Track | High Jump Sectional Champion |
| O’Brien, Kevin | 1990 | LAW | Football | All-City, Academic All-State, All-State and Team |
| Robbins, Eric | 1990 | Football | All-City | |
| Henss, Kate | 1991 | Volleyball | All-City 1990 & 91; Other-All Metro Honorable Mention | |
| Hoop, Darrin | 1991 | Football | All City 1990 & 91; Other-2nd Team All-State | |
| Jackson, Keith | 1991 | Football | All City 1991 & All State 1990 & 91 | |
| Minor, Shawn | 1991 | Baseball | All-City | |
| Phelps, Brian | 1991 | Baseball | All-City | |
| Powell, Jerry | 1991 | CTK | Soccer | All-City team, All-State, Academic All-State |
| Quatman, Caroline | 1991 | Cross Country, Track | State qualifier CC, Regional Champion, State qualifier, 3200 City Champion, 1600 City Champion, State qualifier | |
| Swickheimer, Andy | 1991 | Football, Wrestling | All-City, All-State team, City Champion wrestling,Semi-State Qualifier | |
| Andrews, Ryan | 1992 | Basketball | All-Sectional | |
| Bailey, William | 1992 | Football | All-City, All-State | |
| Baker, Ralph | 1992 | Football | All-City | |
| Church, Katie | 1992 | Tennis | All City 1989 & 92 | |
| Hoover, Shannon | 1992 | Volleyball | All-City | |
| Stephens, Jodie | 1992 | Volleyball | All-City | |
| Bibbs, Kyle | 1993 | Football | All-City, All-State, All-Metro, North/South All Star | |
| Cannon, Ryan | 1993 | Tennis | City Champion #1 Doubles | |
| Costello, Michelle | 1993 | Basketball | All-City | |
| Groves, Pat | 1993 | Football | All-City | |
| Hamilton, Aaron | 1993 | Football | All-City, All-State Guard, All-Marion County | |
| Parker, Bobby | 1993 | Basketball | All-City | |
| Reid, David | 1993 | Football | Team All-State | |
| Bibbs, Dana | 1994 | Volleyball | All-City, All-Metro | |
| Carson, Megan | 1994 | Cross-Country | All-City | |
| Childress, Rod | 1994 | Basketball | All-Sectional, All-Sectional, 1st Team All-City | |
| Coleman, Jamel | 1994 | Football | All-City, All-Metro, All-Marion County, All-State, Bloomington Herald Top 33, North/South All- Star | |
| Condon, Katie | 1994 | Tennis | City Champion #2 Doubles, City Champion #1 Doubles (w/Jackie Stephens) | |
| Degan, Randy | 1994 | Football | All-City, Academic All-State, Academic Top 33, North/South All-Star | |
| Deiter, Elizabeth | 1994 | Softball | All-City | |
| Hedge, Julie | 1994 | Tennis | City Champion #2 Doubles, City Champion #1 Doubles, City Champion #1 Singles | |
| Kavanaugh, Heather | 1994 | SPX | Volleyball | All-City |
| Steeb, Terri | 1994 | Voleyball | All-City, All-Metro, All-State, North-South All Star | |
| Stephens, Jackie | 1994 | Tennis | City Champion #2 Doubles, City Champion #1 Doubles (w/Katie Condon) | |
| Stevens, Jane | 1994 | Swimming | Al-City | |
| Watts, Christi | 1994 | Tennis | City Champion #2 Doubles, City Champion #1 Doubles, City Champion #2 Singles | |
| Conner, Corrie | 1995 | SPX | Volleyball, Softball, Basketball | All-City Volleyball, All-City Basketball, All-City Softball, All-Metro Softball, Hoosier Dianmond All-State Softball, North-South Softball, All-Star, Indianapolis City Athlete of the Year, Marion County Athlete of the Year |
| Currin, Montez | 1995 | Football, Basketball | FB-All-City, All-State; BB-All City, All-Sectional, City/County All-Star | |
| Jennings, Kevin | 1995 | ST | Football, Basketball | All-City, All-State, All-Sectional Basketball, Basketball City/County All-Star |
| Kremer, John | 1995 | CTK | Football, Baseball | All-City, All-State, All-City Baseball, All-State Baseball, Baseball North/South All-Star |
| Milton, Jeremy | 1995 | Wrestling | Sectional Wrestling Champion | |
| Ripperger, Heidi | 1995 | Softball | All-City | |
| Stocker, Sarah | 1995 | Volleyball | All-City | |
| Thatcher, Abby | 1995 | SPX | Volleyball, Basketball, Softball | All-City Volleyball, All-City Basketball tournanment 1st Team, All-City Softball |
| Vonderhaar, David | 1995 | Baseball | All-City, City/County All-Star | |
| Andrews, Jeannine | 1996 | Volleyball/Basketball | All-City, All-Central Zone, All-Marion County, All-Sectional Basketball, All-City Basketball, All-City tournament Basketball, All-marion County Basketball, All-State(Hossier basketball magizine, Indiana Top 100 Basketball Player | |
| Carroll, Keith | 1996 | Basketball | All-City | |
| Clark, Jason | 1996 | Basketball | All-City | |
| Conner, Kacy | 1996 | SPX | Volleyball | All-City |
| Conner, Kyle | 1996 | SPX | Football, Baseball | All-City football. All-City baseball, North/South Football All-Star |
| Crockett, John | 1996 | Tennis | City Champion #1 Singles, All-State, Sectional and Regional Champion, State Finalist | |
| Groves, Betsy | 1996 | Softball | All-City, All-Metro Softball Academic | |
| Harden, Kenny Jr. | 1996 | Football, Baseball | All-City, Herald times All-Star, Coaches top 50 Defensive player, North/South All-Star, All-City Baseball | |
| Linden, Rich | 1996 | Football, Baseball | All-City Football, All-State Football, Academic All-State Football, All-City Baseball, All-State Baseball, North/South Baseball All-Star | |
| Mullin, Paul | 1996 | Football | All-City, Coaches All-State | |
| Noble, Kristin | 1996 | Track, Cross-Country | City Champion, 3200 meter relay, City runner-up, 800 meter dash, Sectional finalist, 800 meter dash, 1600 & 3200 meter relay, All-City cross country | |
| Ryan, Leslie | 1996 | Tennis | City Champion tennis #1 doubles | |
| Sahm, Sarah | 1996 | SPX | Volleyball | All-City, All-Metro |
| Seufert, Kathleen | 1996 | Track | City Champion, 3200 meter relay, City runner-up, 1600 meter run, Sectional finalist, 3200 meter relay, 1600 meter relay | |
| Thatcher, Alex | 1996 | SPX | Basketball | All-City |
| Vonderhaar, Karen | 1996 | Swimming | All-City, City Champion, 100 YD. Freestyle, 100 YD Back stroke | |
| Beeler, Scott | 1997 | Soccer | All-City | |
| Brunette, Lucas | 1997 | Baseball | All-City, City All-Star | |
| Daniels, DuJuan | 1997 | Football | Junior All-State, All-City, Herald Times Top 33, Indianapolis Star City & Metro, Player of The year, All-State running back, North-South All-Star, Indiana’s Mr, Football | |
| Dick, Tony | 1997 | Football | Junior All-State, All-City, All-Metro, First team All-State | |
| Duncan, Matt | 1997 | Soccer | All City | |
| Ferris, David | 1997 | Baseball | USA Today Indiana High School Player of the Year, Indianapolis Start Indianapolis Player of the Year, All-City, City All-Star, North-South All-Star | |
| Fillenwarth, Drew | 1997 | Football | All-Metro, Media All-Star Kicker, All-City, All-State Kicker | |
| Guynn, LaMarkus | 1997 | Basketball | All-Cit, City-County All-Star | |
| Horvath, Nick | 1997 | Baseball | All-City City All-Star, USA Today All-Indiana | |
| Jacobs, Ryan | 1997 | Football | All-City | |
| Kavanaugh, Steve | 1997 | SPX | Football, Basketball | Top 50 All-State, All-City, All-Metro, All-City Basketball, City-County Basketball All-Star |
| Kremer, Andy | 1997 | CTK | Baseball, Tennis | All-City Baseball, City All-Star, USA Today All-Indiana Baseball, City Champion Tennis #1 Doubles |
| Leffler, Jill | 1997 | Cross Country | City Champion 3200 meter relay, City Champion 800 meters, All-City CC, Regional Qualifier CC, | |
| McGuinness, Maureen | 1997 | Tennis | City Champion Tennis #3 Singles, 3 – Sport Academic All-State | |
| Pappas, Jimmy | 1997 | Football | All-City | |
| Schroeder, Ryan | 1997 | SPX | Basketball | All-City, City-County All-Star |
| Seib, John | 1997 | Football | All-City | |
| Traub, Cindy | 1997 | Softball, Volleyball | All-City Softball, City-County All-Star Softball, Academic All-State Volleyball, Academic All-State Softball | |
| Bell, Richard | 1998 | Football | All-City, All-State | |
| Groves, Christine | 1998 | Softball | All-City | |
| Jackson, John | 1998 | Football | All-City, Metro Super Team | |
| Kavanaugh, Karen | 1998 | SPX | Track | 300m hurdle City Champion |
| Kern, Leslie | 1998 | Volleyball | All-City, Academic All-State | |
| Kirk, Mike | 1998 | SPX | Football | All-State |
| Naab, Mike | 1998 | Golf | City Champ 1997 & 98 | |
| Ottenweller, Chris | 1998 | Football, Baseball | All-State, All-City Baseball | |
| Sahm, Andy | 1998 | SPX | Football, Basketball | Herald times All-star, All-City, All-State, North/South All-Star, All-City Basketball, City-County Basketball All-Star |
| Schnieders, Katie | 1998 | LUKE | Tennis, Basketball | City Champion #3 Singles, City Champion #1 Doubles, First Team All-State Doubles, City-County Basketball All-Star |
| Travis, Shawn | 1998 | Baseball | All-City | |
| Vannice, Charlie | 1998 | Football | JR. All-State, All-City, All-State, Indiana’s Top 50 football, North-South All-Star | |
| Watson, Erika | 1998 | Volleyball | All-City 1997, 98 & 99; Indianapolis Star Superteam Player of the Year 1998; All-State 3A Volleyball 1998 | |
| Watts, Angela | 1998 | Tennis | City Champion #2 Doubles, City Champion #1 Doubles, First Team All-State Doubles | |
| Brooks, Jr., Clifford | 1999 | Football | All-City, All-State | |
| DiSalvo, Amy | 1999 | SPX | Volleyball | All-City |
| Flanagan, Josh | 1999 | Baseball | All-City, City-county baseball All-star | |
| Hesemann, Hans | 1999 | Golf | City Champion | |
| Hillier, Sean T. | 1999 | Tennis | City Champ-#1 Doubles | |
| Lannan, Jason | 1999 | Wrestling | Sectional, regional, semi-State, State finalist Champion | |
| Manning, Cesare | 1999 | Football, Track | All-City Football, All-State Football, Indiana’s Top 50 Football, 4 x 400 Relay City Champion | |
| Norris, Keely | 1999 | SPX | Volleyball,Basketball, Track | All-City Volleyball, Indiana All-Star, All-City Basketball, All-City Tourney Team, City-County All-Star, State Finalist, Shot Put |
| Reynolds, Jamie | 1999 | Soccer | All-City soccer | |
| Shaughnessy, John | 1999 | STA | Football, Track | All-State Football, 4 x 400M Relay City Champion |
| Smith, Parker | 1999 | Football | All-City Defense, 3A Honor Team Defense, IFCA Class 3A All-State, IFCA Regional 7 All-Star | |
| Stuber, Kevin | 1999 | Tennis | City Champ-#1 Doubles | |
| Thatcher, Molly | 1999 | SPX | Volleyball, Basketball, Tennis | All-City Volleyball, All-Metro Volleyball, All-City Basketball, All-City Tourney Team, City-County All-Star, #2 Singles Tennis City Champion, #1 Singles Tennis City Champion, MCCGSA City Scholar-Athlete of the Year, Indianapolis Star Female City Athlete of the Year |
| Vonderhaar, Eric | 1999 | Track, Cross Country | 1600m and 3200m City Champion, cross-country individual Champion, 3200 and 4x800m relay Champion | |
| Williams, Kevin | 1999 | Basketball | All-City | |
| Hayenga, Allison | 2000 | Golf, Basketball | Golf-All City 1998 & 99; BB-All City & City-County All-Star 2000 | |
| Heldman, Nick | 2000 | Baseball | All City | |
| Horvath, Noelle | 2000 | Softball | All-City | |
| Kavanaugh, Julie | 2000 | SPX | Softball, Soccer | Softball: All-City, Soccer: MCCGSA All-Marion County, All-City |
| Kremer, Andrea | 2000 | CTK | Cross Coutnry, Softball, Track | Cross-Country: All-State Cross-Country, City Champion Cross-Country, Junior Olympic Nationa Champion, Softball: All-City, Super Team, Track: All-State, City, Sectional, Regional Champion 3200M, City, Sectional, Regional Champion 1600M, City Champion 800M, State Runner-up 3200M, Indianapolis Star City Athlete of the Year, MCCGSA Scholar-Athlete of the year |
| Land, Megan | 2000 | Soccer, Tennis | Soccer: All-City, City-Couty All-Star, Academic All-State, Tennis: City Champion #3 Singles, Academic All-State | |
| Masch, Steve | 2000 | Football | All-City, All-State | |
| Meyer, Sarah | 2000 | Cross Country | All City | Other: Academic All State | |
| Norris, Kristi | 2000 | SPX | Volleyball, Track | All-City Volleyball, City Champioin Discus Throw, State Finalist Shot Put |
| Scheidler, Matt | 2000 | LUKE | Soccer, Football | All-City, Academic All-State Soccer, U.S. Navy Scholastic All-American, All-City Football, All-State Football, Academic All-State |
| Shaughnessy, Brian | 2000 | STA | Soccer, Basketball | Soccer-All City 1998 & 99, North-South All-Star 1999; BB-City-County All-Star | Other-Soccer & BB Academic All-State |
| Smith, Meredith | 2000 | Swimming | City Champ-100y Back 1997-98-99-00, 200y IM 1997 & 99, 400y Free Relay 1999, 200y Medley Relay 2000 | |
| Tekulve, Kristyn | 2000 | SPX | Softball, Swimming | All-City softball, softball academic All-State, City-county All-star, member of swimming relay Champion |
| Wenclewicz, Scott | 2000 | Tennis | City Champion #1 Doubles | |
| Brown, Rebecca | 2001 | Swimming | City Champion 50 Freestyle | |
| Corbito, Maria | 2001 | Cross Country, Track | XC-All City 2000; Track: City Champ- 3200 Relay 2000 & 01, State Qualifier-3200 Relay 2001 | |
| DiSalvo, Joseph | 2001 | SPX | Wrestling | City Champion, Academic All-State |
| Dossman, Emily | 2001 | MATT | Basketball, Track | MCCGSA All-City Basketball, 4 x 800M Relay State Finalist, Catholic City Champion High Jump |
| Downs, Jamison | 2001 | SPX | Tennis | All-District, City Champion #1 Singles, Sectional Champion #1 Singles, Regional Finalist, All-State Tennis |
| Dum, Katie | 2001 | SPX | Volleyball | All-City |
| Fahey, Colin | 2001 | Swimming | City Champion 100 Breaststroke, City Champion individual medley, State finalist, All-American 100 Breaststroke, Member of City Champion Relay Teams | |
| Fitzgerald, Gifford | 2001 | Tennis | City doubles Champion | |
| Flynn, Molly | 2001 | LUKE | Tennis | City Champion #2 Singles, North-South All-Star |
| Fuhrman, Jessica | 2001 | Swimming | City Champion 100 Breaststroke, City Champion individual medley, Member of City Champion RelayTteams | |
| Guimont, Sara | 2001 | MATT | Volleyball, Track | All-City, 4x800M Relay City Champion, 4x800M State Finalist |
| Halliburton, Allan | 2001 | Football | All-City, IFCA All-State, AP All-State | |
| Hughes, Micael | 2001 | Cross Country, Track | XC-City Champ 2000, All City 1998-99, All Sectional & Regional 2000; Track: City Champ-3200 Relay 2000 & 01, State Qualifier-3200 Relay 2001 | |
| Jones, Mike | 2001 | Football | All-City, IFCA All-State, Bloomington Herald All-State, IFCA North-South All-Star | |
| Kern, Lauren | 2001 | LUKE | Volleyball | All-City, Academic All-State |
| Krier, Drew | 2001 | Wrestling | City Champion Wrestling | |
| Miller, Jimmy | 2001 | Baseball | All-City,Academic All-State | |
| Mourey, Jill | 2001 | SPX | Volleyball/Softball | All-City, All-City softball, Academic All-State softball, City-county All-star softball |
| Silvey, Kelly | 2001 | IHM | Basketball, Softball | All-City Basketball, Basketball North-South All-Star, All-City Softball,Softball North-South All-Star, ICGSA All-State Softball |
| Smith, Andy | 2001 | Cross Country | All-City Cross-country, City Champion 800m, 4x400m Relay City Champion | |
| Waymouth, Jaime | 2001 | IHM | Football | AP All-State, Academic All-State |
| Allen, Chris | 2002 | Cross Country | All-City | |
| Andress, Megan | 2002 | Golf | All-City, Golf City Individual Champion, Golf Sectional Individual Champion | |
| Berg, Alex | 2002 | SPX | Football | All State, IFCA 3A |
| Cappel, Kaleena | 2002 | CTK | Cross Country, Track | City Champion cross country, All-City cross country, All-Sectional cross country, All-regional cross country, City Champion 1600m, Catholic City Champion 1600m, Sectional Champion 1600m, State finalist 1600m, MCCGSA City scholar Athlete of the year, 4x800m Relay State finalist, Academic All-State |
| Charles, Aaron | 2002 | CTK | Football | All-City |
| Dalesandro, Nikki | 2002 | MON | Soccer | MCCGSA All-City Soccer, Indianapolis Star All-City Soccer, Academic All-State |
| Jackson, David | 2002 | Football | Star North Football Team | |
| Maloney, Lisa | 2002 | Tennis | City Champion #1 Doubles, All-District Tennis | |
| Morris, Damani | 2002 | Cross Country, Track | All-City Cross Country, City Champion 800M, 4 x 400M Relay City Champion, 4 x 400M Relay State Finalist | |
| Mundell, Andy | 2002 | SPX | Wrestling | City Champion, Outstanding Wrestler – City Tournament, Academic All-State |
| O’Connor, Kelly | 2002 | Tennis | City Champion #2 Doubles, City Champion #1 Doubles, All-District | |
| Petrie, Emily | 2002 | Golf | All-City | |
| Presley, Marques | 2002 | Football | All-City, IFCA3A All-State | |
| Purichia, Susan | 2002 | Softball | All-City Softball | |
| Rago, Valerie | 2002 | SPX | Cross Country, Track | All-City cross country, All-Sectional cross country, All-regional cross country, 3200m State Finalist, 4×800 Relay State finalist |
| Roche, Tim | 2002 | Wrestling | Sectional Champion Wrestling | |
| Sequeira, Sean | 2002 | Tennis | All-District | |
| Sullivan, Jenny | 2002 | SPX | Volleyball | MCCGSA All-City, StarNorth Volleyball Team |
| Zimmerman, Pat | 2002 | Football, Swimming, Track | All-State, 4x400m relay catholic City Champion, 4x400m relay City Champion, 4x400m relay State finalist, All-City | |
| Andress, Brian | 2003 | Football | All City and State Honorable Mention Linebacker, Trojan Toughman of theYear | |
| Baker, Ryan | 2003 | SPX | Football | Indianapolis Star All City, Indianapolis Star North Player of the Year, Gatorade Player of the Year for Indiana, AP First Team All State, High School All American, Indianapolis City Athlete of the Year, Parade High School All American |
| Ball, Sarah | 2003 | MC | Tennis | City Champion #2 Singles,Sectional Doubles Champion, All-District Tennis, Indiana Tennis All-Star, Academic, All-State |
| Barnes, Tony | 2003 | Baseball | All-City, City-County baseball All-star | |
| Betourne, Katie | 2003 | Swimming | City Champion 200 Yard Medley Relay, City Champion 50 Yard Freestyle , City Champion 200 Yard Medley Relay, City Champion 200 Yard Freestyle Relay, City Champion 400 Yard Freestyle Relay Champion | |
| Brunette, Jeff | 2003 | Baseball | All-City, City-County All Star | |
| Cage, Dan | 2003 | SPX | Soccer, Basketball | All-City soccer, All-City basketball, Indianapolis Star City player of the year, Star North Player of the Year, Indianapolis Star Superteam Player of the year, All-State, IBCA top 15 players, City-county All-star, State finals MVP, Indiana All-star, McDonald’s All-American Nominee, Academic All-star |
| Corbito, Anna | 2003 | Track & Field | Catholic City Champion 300m hurdles, Regional qualifier 300M hurdles, Regional qualifier 100m hurdles, 4x400m relay Champions | |
| Corbito, Laura | 2003 | Track & Field | All-State Discus | |
| Dossman, Natalie | 2003 | MATT | Volleyball | MCCGSA 1st team All-City, Indianapolis star north 2nd team All-City, Indianapolis star second team All-City, Indiana jr. All-star, All-st./All-star nominee, Indianapolis star north 1st team All-City, Indianapolis star 1st team All-City |
| Dury, Mike | 2003 | SPX | Football, Baseball, Basketball | All-City Baseball, Indianapolis Star Player of the year, Star North Baseball Team, Indianapolis Star Superteam, Indiana Baseball All-Star, City-county Baseball All-Star, City-county Basketball All-Star, All-City Foorball, Indianapolis Star Player of the year, Star North Football Team, All-State Football, North/South All-star, Academic All-State, Indianapolis Star City Athlete of the year, WRTV Channel 6 Star of the Year, Arthur L. Trester Award, Phil N. Eskew Award |
| Early, Bart | 2003 | SPX | Fooball, Baseball | Football All City and All Sate, football All City, State and Star North Team, Baseball All City Team |
| Hamilton, Scott | 2003 | Baseball | All-City, City-County baseball All-star | |
| Karas, Nick | 2003 | Golf | Golf City Champion, Regional qualifier | |
| Kline, Anna | 2003 | SPX | Cross Country | All-City cross-country, academic All-st. cross-country |
| Laycock, Laura | 2003 | Softball | MCCGSA All-City, MCCGSA All-Star | |
| Mark, Greg | 2003 | Swimming | City Champion 50 Yard Freestyle, City Champion 100 Yard Freestyle, City Champion 200 Yard Medley Relay, City Champion 100 Yard Fly | |
| Mason, Vincent Jr. | 2003 | Football, Track | All-City football, Indianapolis star football City player of the year, IFCA All-State football, AP All-State football, Catholic City Champion 400m, catholic City long jump Sectional campion 400m, 400m State finalist, 4x400m Relay catholic City Champion, 4x400m Relay City Champion, 4x400m Relay State finalist | |
| McGonigal, Caitlin | 2003 | SPX | Softball, Basketball | MCCGSA All-City Softball, MCCGSA Softball All-Star, MCCGSA All-City Basketball, Academic All-State Basketball |
| McLain, Kelly | 2003 | SPX | Softball | MCCGSA All-City, Indianapolis Star All-City, MCCGSA All-Star |
| Mourey, Carly | 2003 | SPX | Softball | MCCGSA All-City, MCCGSA All-Star |
| Murrell, Brandi | 2003 | Cross Country, Track | All-City cross country, All-Sectional cross country, All-regional cross country, All-State cross country, Indiana All-Star, City Champion 400m, City Champion 800m, All-State 800m, 4x400M Relay Champion, 4x800M Relay State Qualifiers | |
| Norris, Katie | 2003 | SPX | Volleyball, Basketball, Track | MCCGSA All-City Volleyball, Indianapolis Star, All-City Volleyball, Indiana Junior All-Star, StarNorth Volleyball Team, Indianapolis Star Superteam, ICGSA All-State Volleyball, Academic, All-State Basketball, Shot Put and Discus City Champion, Shot Put Catholic City Champion, Discus Catholic City Champion, Shot Put and Discus Sectional Champion, Shot Put and Discus Regional Champion, All-State Discus, All-State Shot Put |
| Popp, Melissa | 2003 | LAW | Volleyball, Basketball | MCCGSA All-City, Indindapolis Star All-City, Indiana Junior All-Star, Indianapolis Star player of the year, Star North Volleyball team, Star North Player of the year, Indianapolis Star superteam, Indianapolis Star superteam player of the year, ICGSA All-State villeyball, MCCGSA All-City basketball, MCCGSA City Athlete of the Year, Indianapolis Star City Athlete of the year |
| Prickel, A.J. | 2003 | Baseball | All-City, Indianapolis Star Player of the year, City-County baseball All-Star | |
| Roach, Mike | 2003 | Soccer | ISCA Top Team Player, MVP, All-City 1st Team | |
| Roszkowski, Lindsey | 2003 | Golf | Golf team City Champion, individual All-City, individual top 10 City, Golf team Sectional Camps. | |
| Ruberg, Monica | 2003 | Volleyball | MCCGSA 1st team All-City, academic All-st., Indianapolis star north 2nd team All-City, Indianapolis star 2nd team All-City | |
| Scheidler, Amy | 2003 | LUKE | Soccer | MCCGSA All-City, Indianapolis Star All-City, Academic All-State, All-District, Bishop Chatatrd Female Athlete of the Year |
| Wade, Jamaal | 2003 | Basketball | All-City | |
| Young, Steve | 2003 | Football | Associated press 3A 1st team All st., Indiana football coaches AP All st. team, Indianapolis star All City team, Bloomington Herald 1st team All st. | |
| Alexander, Jeff | 2004 | Baseball | Indianapolis Star All-City | |
| Andress, Molly | 2004 | Softball, Golf | All-City girls golf, City golf team Champions, Sectional golf team Champions, All-City softball | |
| Ball, Emily | 2004 | MC | Golf | All-City girls golf, City golf team Champions, Sectional Golf Team Champions |
| Beaven, Michael | 2004 | Baseball | Indianapolis Star All-City, City/County All-State | |
| Carson, Pat | 2004 | Track | City high jump Champion, 4x800m City Champion relay team, NSR indoor track/fields smAll school st. high jump Champion | |
| Clark, Anna | 2004 | Track | City Champ-3200 Relay 2004, State Qualifier-3200 Relay 2002-03-04 | Other: All Catholic Champion 3200 Relay | |
| Clark, Celine | 2004 | Soccer | Indianapolis Star All-City Player, MCGSA All-City Player | |
| Coleman, Jonas | 2004 | SJA | Basketball | All-City boys basketball |
| Danforth, Rachel | 2004 | Soccer | All-City, Academic All State | |
| DiSalvo, Derek | 2004 | SPX | Football | All State 1st Team, Academic All State, Indianaplis Star All City, Indianapolis star North All City, North/ South All Star Team |
| Dodson, Patrick | 2004 | SPX | Golf | All City |
| Dominguez, Katie | 2004 | CTK | Cross Country, Track | XC-All City 2001-02-03-04; Track: City Champ-3200 Relay 2004, State Qualifier-3200 Relay 2003-04-05 |
| Dorsey, Meghan | 2004 | Tennis | City Champion #2 doubles, Indiana North/South All-star, All-st. honorable mention | |
| Dury, Tim | 2004 | SPX | Football | Bloomington Herald times- All-State Team, AP All State; Indianapolis star- All City, All-metro, top 50 metro player, top 20 north player |
| Fairchild, Kimmie | 2004 | LUKE | Tennis | City Champion # 2 singles, Sectional champoin #1 doubles, Indiana North/South All-star, All-st. honorable mention |
| Fairchild, Kyle | 2004 | LUKE | Golf, Tennis | Te – City Champion #1 doubles Golf – All-City |
| Gardner, Sarah | 2004 | STA | Volleyball | MCCGSA All City, Indianapolis star north 1st team, Indiana All star, All State honorable mention |
| Guimont, Tim | 2004 | Cross Country | All City Cross Country | |
| Jones, David | 2004 | Baseball | Indianapolis Star 1st Team All-City | |
| Leffler, Eric | 2004 | Track, Cross Country | City Champion 800M, City Champion 4X800 Relay, State Qualifier, All-City Cross Country, 7th in State 4X800 | |
| Leone, Kristen | 2004 | SPX | Tennis, Volleyball | All-City volleyball team, All-metro volleyball team, Indianapolis star north honorable mention, All-st. nominee, North/south All-star nominee, All-District tenis team, north/south senior All-star tenis team, All-st. honorable mention |
| Mattingly, Carly | 2004 | SPX | Volleyball | MCCGSA All City, Indianapolis star north 2nd team, Indiana All star |
| Mulvaney, Meghan | 2004 | SPX | Tennis | All-St. honorable mention, Indiana North/South All-star |
| O’Connor, Colleen | 2004 | Soccer | Media All-City, ISCA Academic All-State | |
| Petrie, Julia | 2004 | Golf | All City, Sectional Medalist/Champion | |
| Prickel, Danielle | 2004 | Soccer | MCCGSA All-City, Media All-City | |
| Schaffner, John Michael | 2004 | SPX | Football | All-City |
| Scheidler, Jimmy | 2004 | LUKE | Football | All City & metro |
| Schroeder, Emily | 2004 | SPX | Volleyball | MCCGSA All City & State, Indiana jr. All star, Indianapolies star super team, star north 1st team All City, indian All star |
| Stephenson, Nick | 2004 | Cross Country, Track | cross-country most improved runner, track 4x800m relay-All-City relay 3rd place, track 4x800m relay-City champs, track 2 mile- All-City 5th place, | |
| Watson, Kris | 2004 | Track, Cross Country | City Champion 1600m relay, City Champion 3200m relay, cross-country City Champions | |
| Ball, Kevin | 2005 | MC | Football | All-City Kicker, Academic All-State |
| Ball, Seth | 2005 | IHM | Track, Cross Country | Track: 3200M Realy Member State Champion Team, Cross Country: Indianaplis Star All-City, Honorable Mention All-State, Academic All-State |
| Bill, Brittany | 2005 | CTK | Cross Country, Track | Cross Country MCCGSA All-City, State Qualifier, 3rd Team All-State, All-State Honorable Mention, Track: City Champion 3200M, State Qualifier |
| Brown, Allie | 2005 | Golf | MCCGSA All-City | |
| Buhler, Josh | 2005 | MATT | Track | City Champ-1600 Relay, State Finalist-400 Relay & 1600 Relay | Other: All Catholic Champion-1600 relay |
| Candler, Blake | 2005 | Track | All Catholic Champion | |
| Carriger, Kevan | 2005 | Football | Bloomington Herald Junior- All-State Team, IFCA All-State, Indianapolis Star Super Team, Indianapolis Star North Team, All- City and All Conference, Academic All-State | |
| Copeland, Laura | 2005 | Soccer | MCCGSA All-City, Indianapolis star All-City team, Morth/South All-star | |
| Dalesandro, Tony | 2005 | MON | Football | AP All-State, Indianapolis Star North Team, Academic All-State, All-City |
| Dietrick, Chris | 2005 | SPX | Track, Cross Country | 3200M Relay Member State Champion Team, Cross Country: Indianapolis Star All-City, All- Sectional, Honorable Mention All-State |
| Feeney, Charlie | 2005 | CTK | Football | IFCA All-State, All-City, Academic All-State |
| Franklin, Natalie | 2005 | Soccer, Track | MCCGSA All-City soccer, Media All-City soccer, North/South senior All star, ISCA Academic All State, City Champion 4x400m Relay, City Champion 4x100m Relay | |
| Gilmore, Lucy | 2005 | Swimming | City Champion 100YD. Fly Event, All-City 200 Medley Relay, All-City 400 Medley Relay | |
| Golobish, Brian | 2005 | Soccer | All-City, Acaemic All-State | |
| HAlliburton, Frank | 2005 | Football | All City & State, Top 50 Player, Bloomington Herald All State, Indiana All Star | |
| Homan, Alex | 2005 | Soccer | All-City, Academic All-State, All-District 2nd team | |
| Hyde, Lauren | 2005 | LUKE | Soccer | MCCGSA All-City, ISCA 1st team All District, ISCA academic All State, Indianapolis star All-City, ICGSA 1st team All-State |
| Jones, Sean | 2005 | Wrestling | City Champion 189 LBS. | |
| Kavanaugh, Colleen | 2005 | Golf | MCCGSA All-City, City Champion, State Qualifier | |
| Mason, Dray | 2005 | LUKE | Football, Track | All City, Metro, State; Bloomington Herald All-State, Bloomington Herald Top 50 Player, Indiana All-star, Mr. Football Finalist, City Champion in the 100, All catholic Champion 4×100 & 100, Indianapolis star male Athlete of the year |
| McGonigal, Meghan | 2005 | SPX | Softball, Swimming | All-City softball, academic All-st. softball, academic All-st. swimming |
| McNelis, Michael | 2005 | MATT | Football, Wrestling, Track | Junior All City & State, All City & metro, academic All State, Heacy weight City Champion, academic All State, City Champion shot put, academic All State |
| Metzger, Nick | 2005 | IHM | Cross Country, Track | All-City, City Champion Pole Vault |
| Norris, Kortney | 2005 | SPX | Volleyball, Track | inidanapolis Star All City, Indianapolis Star North Player of the Year, Gatorade Player of the Year for Indiana, AP First Team All State, High School All American, Indianapolis City Athlete of the Year, Parade High School All American |
| O’Donnell, Nola | 2005 | Swimming | All-City 100 Backstroke, All-City 200 Yard Freestyle Relay, Academic All- State Swimming | |
| Popp, Whitney | 2005 | LAW | Track | City Champ-3200 Relay 2004, State Qualifier-3200 Relay 2003-04-05 | Other: All Catholic Champ 3200 Relay |
| Tekulve, Brian | 2005 | SPX | Baseball | 1st team All City baseball |
| Wagner, Stacey | 2005 | LUKE | Basketball | All-City Marion county coaches association |
| Ware, Monique | 2005 | CTK | Track | City Champ-LJ 2004 & 05, City Champ-400 Relay 2005, State Finalist-LJ 2005 | Other: All Catholic Champion 400 Relay |
| Wilkerson, Audrey | 2005 | Swimming | City Champ-200 IM & 500 Free 2002, City Champ-200 Medley Relay 2002-03-05, City Champ-100 Back & 400 Free Relay 2003, State Finalist-100 Back 2005 | Other: Academic All State Honorable Mention, Top 16 State Finalist 100 Backstroke | |
| Armbrust, Jason | 2006 | Golf | All-City | |
| Barclay, Ross | 2006 | Golf | All-City | |
| Brehm, Lauren | 2006 | SPX | Softball | All City |
| Buhler, Ben | 2006 | MATT | Football | All State |
| Carr, Matt | 2006 | LAW | Baseball, Football | Baseball All-City, Football Bloomington Hereald Junior All-State, Academic All-State |
| Coutz, Melissa | 2006 | NC | Softball | MCCGSA All-City |
| Fohl, Lauren | 2006 | SPX | Soccer, Tennis | MCCGSA All-City, ISCA academic All-State, ISCA team Top Player, ISCA Academic All-State, ICGSA Academic All-star, MCCGSA All-City, IHSTCA Academic All-State |
| Hart, Jake | 2006 | STA | Football | All State |
| Higgenbottom, Matt | 2006 | Soccer | All City | |
| Holzhausen, Laura | 2006 | Volleyball | All City | |
| Johnstone, Katie | 2006 | SPX | Softball | MCCGSA All-City, Indianaplis Star All-City |
| Leone, Todd | 2006 | SPX | Football, Track | Indianapolis Star City Male Athlete of the Year, Football: All-City, IFCA All-State, Bloomington Herald All-State Team,Track: 3200M Realay Member State Champion Team, City 800M Champion, Sectional 800M Champion |
| Martin, Josh | 2006 | MATT | Football | All City, All State |
| McCAlley, Erin | 2006 | SPX | Softball | MCCGSA All-City |
| Muchler, Dan | 2006 | MON | Football | All City |
| Neufer, Amanda | 2006 | Softball | All City | |
| Reed, Beth | 2006 | SPX | Soccer, Basketball, Softball | Indianapolis star City female Athlete of the year, MCCGSA City Athlete of the year, NSCAA Academic All-american team, All-City soccer, Indianapolis star All-City team, Indianapolis star north team, ICGSA All-State soccer 2nd team, ICGSA academic All-State, ICGSA academic All-State, All-City, ISGSA Academic All-State |
| Robinson, Justin | 2006 | AND | Football | All City & All State |
| Salyer, Catie | 2006 | IHM | Cross Country | All City, Sectional & Regional |
| Seeber, Jennifer | 2006 | STA | Basketball | MCCGSA All-City |
| White, Kevin | 2006 | MATT | Football | All State |
| Zirrillo, Jessica | 2006 | LAW | Volleyball, Softball | ICGSA All-State, All-City, Indianapolis Star Super Team, Indiana All-Star Team, Sftball MCCGSA All-City |
| Alerding, Ellen | 2007 | MATT | Volleyball | All City |
| Barnes, Annie | 2007 | Track | City Champ & State Finalist, 1600M Relay | |
| Bastnagel, Brittany | 2007 | SPX | Soccer | All City |
| Burns, Chelsea | 2007 | SIM | Soccer, Cross Country | Soccer-All City & District; XC-All City |
| Cappel, Maggie | 2007 | CTK | Track | City Champ & State Finalist, 1600M Relay |
| Catton, Will | 2007 | SPX | Golf | All City |
| Davis, Amy | 2007 | IHM | Cross Country, Track | XC-All City, Sectional & Regional; Track-State Finalist, 3200M Relay |
| Dietrick, Kyle | 2007 | SPX | Football | All City, All State, Indiana All Star |
| DiSalvo, Natalie | 2007 | SPX | Track | City Champ & State Finalist, 400 Relay |
| Dodson, Matt | 2007 | SPX | Golf | City Medalist/Champ |
| Fillenwarth, Christy | 2007 | Soccer | All City | |
| Gardner, Kelly | 2007 | STA | Basketball, Track | BB-All City, Jr. All Star, SUPERTEAM; Track-City & Sectional Champ, State Qualifier |
| Higgenbottom, Ally | 2007 | Soccer | All City | |
| Holland, Joe | 2007 | SIM | Footbal, Track | FB-All City, North, State, SUPERTEAM; Track-City Champ-1600 Relay, State Finalist-400 & 1600 Relay; City Athlete of the Year |
| Hyde, Lindsey | 2007 | LUKE | Soccer | All City |
| Kempf, Attie | 2007 | Swimming | City Champ-200 Medley Relay | |
| Kleinschmidt, Tyler | 2007 | CTK | Football, Basketball | FB-All State; BB-All City, City-County All Star |
| Kremer, Aaron | 2007 | CTK | Cross Country, Track | XC-City Champ, All Sectional, Regional, Semi-State & All State; Track-City Champ, 3200M |
| Laconi, Lindsey | 2007 | SIM | Cross Country | All City, Sectional, Regional |
| McNelis, Sara | 2007 | MATT | Tennis | All District |
| Metzger, Kristen | 2007 | LUKE | Tennis | City Champ-#1 Doubles, All District |
| Oakley, Lizzie | 2007 | MATT | Swimming | City Champ-200 Medley Relay |
| O’Brien, Courtney | 2007 | LUKE | Volleyball, Tennis | VB-All City; Tennis-City Champ, #1 Doubles, All District |
| Poore, Andrew | 2007 | CTK | Cross Country, Track | XC-City, Sectional, Regional Champ, All Semi-State & All State; Track-City Champ-800, 1600, 3200, 3200 Relay; Sectional & Regional Champ-3200 & 3200 Relay; State Finalist-3200; STATE Champ-3200 Relay |
| Robinson, Cosmo | 2007 | Track | City Champ-HJ | |
| Robinson, Ebony | 2007 | Track | City Champ-100, 400 Relay & 1600 Relay; Sectional Champ-100; State Finalist-400 Relay & 1600 Relay | |
| Scheidler, Julie | 2007 | LUKE | Soccer | All City, North, SUPERTEAM, All State; Indiana’s Miss Soccer, All American; City Athlete of the Year |
| Sklorenko, Mark | 2007 | Cross Country | All City | |
| Smith, Ellie | 2007 | Swimming | City Champ-200 Medley Relay | |
| Stimpson, Molly | 2007 | MATT | Softball | All City |
| Vargas, Melissa | 2007 | Tennis | All District | |
| Vaughn, Jeff | 2007 | Football | All State | |
| Wilkerson, Graham | 2007 | Football | All State | |
| Boese, Anne | 2008 | LUKE | Basketball | All City, SUPERTEAM, All State |
| Doyle, Rob | 2008 | SPX | Baseball | All City |
| Dum, Michael | 2008 | SPX | Football, Wrestling | FB-All City, All State; Wr-City & Regional Champ, SUPERTEAM, State Qualifier |
| Dury, John | 2008 | SPX | Football, Baseball | FB-All City, SUPERTEAM, All State, Indiana All Star; Baseball-All City, All State; City Athlete of the Year |
| Gardner, Megan | 2008 | STA | Basketball | All City |
| Kennedy, Jimmy | 2008 | LUKE | Basketball | All City, City-County All Star |
| Kirkhoff, Patrick | 2008 | Soccer | All City (Indy Star) 2005 | |
| Mourey, Scott | 2008 | SPX | Baseball | All City, All State |
| Muskat, Kate | 2008 | IHM | Track | City Champion, 100-200-400 Relay-HJ; Sectional Champ, 100; State Finalist, 100-200-400 Relay |
| O’Brien, Pat | 2008 | LUKE | Golf | All City |
| Schutzman, Caroline | 2008 | LUKE | Basketball | All City |
| White, Billy | 2008 | MATT | Baseball | All City |
| Akin, Bobby | 2009 | MC | Football | All State (IFCA) 2008 |
| Boyce, Emily | 2009 | CTK | Cross Country, Track | All City(MCCGSA) 2008; All Sectional 2007 & 08; City Champion (3200M Relay-2008 &09); Regional Champion & State 2nd Place (3200M Relay-2009) |
| Burkert, Katy | 2009 | MATT | Track | City Champion (1600M Relay-2008) |
| Coutz, Amy | 2009 | NC | Softball | All City(MCCGSA) 2007, 08 & 09 |
| Crawford, Kourtney | 2009 | LAW | Basketball, Track, Volleyball | All City (MCCGSA & Indy Star 2009); City-County All Star; City Champion (400M Relay-2006 &07); State 3rd Place (400M Relay-2006); All City (MCCGSA & Indy Star) 2008 |
| Holzhausen, Jake | 2009 | Golf | All City 2009 | |
| Hurrle, Daniel | 2009 | IHM | Football, Track | All City (Indy Star) 2008; All State (IFCA) 2008; City Champion (High Jump-2008 & 09); State Finalist (High Jump-2008) |
| Kennedy, Pat | 2009 | LUKE | Basketball | City-County All Star 2009 |
| Kessing, Lauren | 2009 | IHM | Tennis | All District (IHSTeCA) 2008 & 09 |
| Maniago, Steve | 2009 | IHM | Baseball | All City (Indy Star & City Baseball Coaches Assoc. 2009) |
| Martin, Zach | 2009 | MATT | Football | All City(Indy Star) 2007 & 08; SUPERTEAM 2008; All State(AP & IFCA) 2006, 07 &08; All American (ESPN) 2008 |
| McKiernan-Allen, Sabbath | 2009 | Soccer | All City(Indy Star & MCCGSA) 2006, 07 & 08 | |
| McLaughlin, Jack | 2009 | Rugby | All State 2007, 08 & 09 | |
| Metzger, Alex | 2009 | IHM | Track | City Champion (Pole Vault 2007, 08 & 09); State Finalist (Pole Vault-2007 & 08); State 3rd Place (Pole Vault-2009) |
| Nesbesny, Angela | 2009 | SIM | Cross Country, Track | All City(MCCGSA) 2006, 07 & 08; All Sectional 2007 City Champion (3200M Relay-2009) |
| Parsons, Michael | 2009 | LAW | Golf | All City 2009 |
| Parsons, Mureen | 2009 | LAW | Golf | All City(MCCGSA) 2006 & 07 |
| Salyer, Christen | 2009 | IHM | Cross Country, Track | All City (MCCGSA) 2008; City Champion (3200M Relay-2008 & 09) |
| Sobolewski, Carly | 2009 | MATT | Cross Country, Track | All City(MCCGSA), All Sectional & Regional 2006 & 07; All Semi-State & All State 2007; City Champion (3200M-2007, 08 & 09); Sectional & Regional Champion (3200M-2008); State Finalist (3200m Relay-2007); State 3rd Place (3200M-2008) |
| Tekulve, Kellie | 2009 | SPX | Softball | All City(MCCGSA) 2008 & 09 |
| Turk, Rob | 2009 | Golf | All City 2009 | |
| Tyler, Kim | 2009 | CTK | Softball | All City(Indy Star 2009 & MCCGSA 2008 & 09) |
| Webber, Jackson | 2009 | Cross Country | All City 2007 & 08; All Sectional 2008 | |
| Agnew, TJ | 2010 | SPX | Baseball | All City (Indy Star & City Baseball Coaches Assoc.) 2010 |
| Bill, Anthony | 2010 | CTK | Wrestling | City Champion (160#-2008 & 171#-2009); City Wrestler of the Year 2009; Sectional Champion 2008; Regional Champion 2010; State Qualifier 2009; State Finalist 2010 |
| Blackburn, Chris | 2010 | Track | City Champion (300M Hurdles & 1600M Relay 2010); State Finalist (300M Hurdles 2010) | |
| Burns, McKenzie | 2010 | SIM | Soccer | All City (MCCGSA & Indy Star) 2009 |
| Cheesman, Morgan | 2010 | Softball | All City (MCCGSA) 2010; City-County All Star 2010 | |
| Craig, Jillian | 2010 | LAW | Basketball, Softball | BB-City-County All Star / Softball-All City (MCCGSA & Indy Star) 2010; City-County All Star 2010 |
| Dickson, Cody | 2010 | Football | All City (Indy Star); All State (IFCA & AP) 2009 | |
| Fohl, Eric | 2010 | SPX | Tennis | All District (IHSTeCA) 2008 & 09 |
| Hill, Amy | 2010 | LAW | Softball | City-County All Star 2010 |
| Hill, Kelly | 2010 | LAW | Softball | City-County All Star 2010 |
| Holland, Marianne | 2010 | SIM | Track | City Champion (1600M Relay 2007 & 08) |
| Holland, Michael | 2010 | Swimming | City Champion (50y & 100y Freestyle 2008 & 09) | |
| Kilbane, Molly | 2010 | SIM | Softball | All City (MCCGSA & Indy Star) 2009 & 10; City-County All Star 2010 |
| Kimack, Rachael | 2010 | LUKE | Soccer, Basketball, Track | Soccer-All City (MCCGSA & Indy Star) 2008 & 09; All District 2009 / Basketball-City-County All Star 2010 / Track-City Champion (1600M & 3200M Relays 2008, 3200M Relay 2010) |
| Kirby, Christine | 2010 | IHM | Cross Country, Track | XC-All City (MCCGSA) 2006, 07, 08; All Sectional 2006, 07, 08; All Regional 2006, 07 / Track-City Champion (800M-2007, 09, 10 : 1600M Relay-2007, 08, 10 : 3200M Relay-2008, 09, 10); Sectional Champion (3200M Relay 2010); Regional Champion (800M-2007 : 3200M Relay-2009, 10); State Qualifier (1600M Relay 2007); State Finalist (800M-2007, 09, 10 : 3200M-Relay 2007, 10 : 1600M Relay-2010); State 2nd Place (3200M Relay 2009) |
| Kirschner, Nikki | 2010 | SIM | Cross Country | All City (MCCGSA) 2008 & 09 |
| Laconi, Paige | 2010 | SIM | Track | City Champion (400M Relay-2007 : 1600M Relay-2010); Sectional & Regional Champion (3200M Relay 2010); State Finalist (1600M & 3200M Relays-2010 |
| Lucas, Chris | 2010 | CTK | Wrestling | City & Sectional Champion (145#-2009-10) |
| Pappas, Aristotle | 2010 | Football | All City (Indy Star) 2008, 09; Indy Star SUPERTEAM 2009; All State (IFCA) 2007, 08, 09; Indiana All Star | |
| Paras, Lauren | 2010 | LUKE | Tennis | All District (IHSTeCA) 2009 & 10; Indiana North-South All Star 2010 |
| Reidy, Becca | 2010 | LAW | Volleyball | All City (MCCGSA & Indy Star) 2008, 09; City Player of the Year 2009; Indy Star SUPERTEAM 2009 |
| Wayer, Taylor | 2010 | SIM | Basketball | All City (City Tournament Team) 2010 |
| Weaver, Kathleen | 2010 | SPX | Swimming | City Champion (200y Medley Relay 2007; 200y IM & 100y Breastroke 2009) |
| Zimmerman, Mary | 2010 | SLDM | Swimming/Diving | City Champion (Diving 2009) |
| Adkins, Michael | 2011 | SIM | Football | All City (Indy Star) 2010 |
| Arias, Sara | 2011 | IHM | Volleyball | All City (Indy Star) 2010 |
| Boyce, Nick | 2011 | CTK | Cross Country | All City 2009 & 10 |
| Deitchman, Eric | 2011 | MATT | Football | All City (Indy Star) 2010; All State (IFCA 2009 & 10, and AP 2010); Indiana All Star 2010; City Athlete of the Year (Indy Star) 2011 |
| Dodson, Maggie | 2011 | SPX | Golf | All City (MCCGSA) 2008, 09 & 10 |
| Doyle, Cathy | 2011 | SIM | Golf, Basketball | Golf-All City & Sectional 2010; BB-All City (Tourney Team, MCCGSA & Indy Star) 2010 & 11; City-County All Star 2011 |
| Fagan, Patrick | 2011 | SPX | Football | All City (Indy Star) 2009; All State (IFCA) 2010 |
| Fehribach, Joe | 2011 | SIM | Wrestling | City Champion (189 lbs) 2010; State Qualifier 2011 |
| Guzek, Teddy | 2011 | SIM | Track | City Champion (1600M Relay) 2010 |
| Jansen, Christopher | 2011 | Baseball | All City (City Baseball Coaches 2010 & 11 and Indy Star 2011); City Co-Player of the Year 2011; SUPERTEAM (Indy Star) 2011 | |
| Kimack, Nikki | 2011 | LUKE | Soccer | All City (MCCGSA) 2010 |
| LaRose, Kenny | 2011 | CTK | Football | All City & SUPERTEAM (Indy Star) 2010; All State (IFCA 2009 & AP 2010) |
| Mark, Joe | 2011 | IHM | Track | City Champion (1600M Relay 2010) & (300M Hurdles 2011) |
| Martin, Nick | 2011 | MATT | Football | All City & SUPERTEAM (Indy Star) 2010; All State (IFCA & AP 2010) |
| Miller, Nolan | 2011 | MATT | Lacrosse | All State (IHSLA) 2011 |
| Queisser, Cory | 2011 | SIM | Soccer | All City (Indy Star) 2009 |
| Queisser, Kylie | 2011 | SIM | Soccer | All City (MCCGSA) 2008 |
| Rivelli, Patrick | 2011 | CTK | Wrestling | City Champion (160 lbs) 2010 |
| Schueth, Elizabeth | 2011 | SIM | Basketball | All City (Tourney Team) 2011 |
| Shaughnessy, Katie | 2011 | STA | Volleyball, Basketball, Track | VB-All City (MCCGSA) 2008, 09 & 10; BB-All City (Tourney Team & MCCGSA) 2010; Track-City Champion (1600M Relay) 2011 |
| Soffera, Daniel | 2011 | SIM | Cross Country | All City 2010 |
| Soffera, Will | 2011 | SIM | Baseball | All (Indy Star) 2011 |
| Stahl, Erica | 2011 | LAW | Volleyball | All City (MCCGSA & Indy Star) 2009 & 10 |
| Ward, Rachel | 2011 | SIM | Lacrosse | All State (Indiana Women’s Lacrosse Assoc.) 2010 & 2011; Honorable Mention All American (USLacrosse) 2011; All American (ESPN) 2011 |
| Williamson, Casey | 2011 | LUKE | Softball | All City (Indy Star & MCCGSA) 2008, 09, 10 & 11; City Player of the Year 2010; All District 2009, 10 & 11; SUPERTEAM (Indy Star) 2010 & 11; City-County All Star 2011 |
| Anvoots, Sid | 2012 | Football | All City (City Coaches) 2011; SUPERTEAM (Indy Star) 2011; All State (AP) 2011 | |
| Barnes, Zane | 2012 | LAW | Baseball | All City (City Coaches) 2012 |
| Barron, Katelyn | 2012 | MON | Soccer | All City (MCCGSA & Indy Star) 2009, 10, 11; All-City Tournament Team 2011; All District (ISCA) 2010 |
| Beals, Ian | 2012 | MON | Soccer | All City (Indy Star & City Coaches) 2010, 11 |
| Bell, Maggie | 2012 | SIM | Cross Country, Track | XC: All City (MCCGSA) & Sectional 2011 | Track: Regional Champion & State 2nd Place (3200M Relay-2009); City Champion (100M, 200M & 400M-2010); Sectional & Regional Champion (3200M Relay-2010); State Finalist (1600M & 3200M Relays 2010); City Champion (100M, 400M & 1600M Relay-2011); State 2nd Place (400M-2011 & 2012); City Champion (100M, 200M & 1600M Relay-2011); Indiana All Star 2012 |
| Bill, Anthony | 2012 | CTK | Football, Wrestling | Football: All City (City Coaches) 2011; All State (AP) 2011 | Wrestling: City Champion (195 lbs.) 2011 |
| Burch, Arden | 2012 | CTK | Cross Country, Track | XC: All City & Sectional 2010, 11 | Track: City Champion (3200M Relay-2010 & 3200M-2011); City Champion (3200M Relay-2012) Sectional Champion (3200M Relay-2011 & 2012); Regional Champion (3200M Relay-2012); State Finalist (3200M Relay-2011); State 2nd Place (3200M-2012) |
| Crafton, Paige | 2012 | MATT | Golf | City Medalist/Champion 2008, 10, 11; All City 2009; All Sectional 2008, 11; Sectional Medalist/Champion 2009 & 10; All Regional 2009, 11; Regional Medalist/Champion 2010; State Finalist 2009, 10, 11; All State 2010, 11 |
| Davis, Mary | 2012 | IHM | Cross Country, Track | XC: All City (MCCGSA) 2008, 10, 11; All Sectional, Regional, Semi-State & State 2008 & 09; City & Sectional Champion 2010, 11; All Regional & Semi-State 2010, 11; State Qualifier 2008, 09, 10, 11; All State 2010, 11; Indiana All Star 2011 | Track: City, Sectional & Regional Champion & State Finalist (1600M-2009); Regional Champion & State 2nd Place (3200M Relay-2009); City Champion (1600M & 3200M-2010); Sectional & Regional Champion (3200M Relay-2010 & 2012); City Champion (800M & 1600M-2011); Regional Champion (1600M-2011); State Finalist (1600M & 3200M-2011); City Champion (800M & 1600M & 1600M Relay-2012); Sectional & Regional Champion (800M & 3200M Relay-2012); State Finalist (800M & 1600M Relay-2012); State 2nd Place (3200M Relay-2012); Indiana All Star 2012 | City Athlete-of-the-Year (MCCGSA) 2012 |
| Dietrick, Annie | 2012 | SPX | Cross Country | All City (MCCGSA) 2009; All Sectional 2008 |
| Doyle, Teddi | 2012 | MATT | Tennis | All District (IHSTeCA) 2011, 12 |
| Gardner, Greg | 2012 | STA | Basketball | City-County All Star 2012 |
| Germano, Joe | 2012 | Tennis | All District (IHSTeCA) 2010, 11 | |
| Hepp, Aaron | 2012 | SIM | Football | All City & City Player of the Year (City Coaches) 2011; All State (IFCA) 2011; Indiana All Star |
| Keating, Colleen | 2012 | MATT | Soccer | All City (MCCGSA) 2009 |
| Kelly-Hooks, Brent | 2012 | AND | Football | All City (City Coaches) 2011 |
| Kleinschmidt, Ryan | 2012 | CTK | Football | All City (Indy Star/City Coaches) 2010, 11; All State (IFCA & AP) 2010, 11 |
| Malone-Wright, Myles | 2012 | Football | All City (City Coaches) 2011 | |
| McBeath, Casey | 2012 | SIM | Soccer | All City (City Coaches) 2011 |
| Nightingale, Emily | 2012 | IHM | Tennis | All District (IHSTeCA) 2011, 12 |
| O’Brien, Heather | 2012 | LUKE | Tennis, Track | Tennis: All District (IHSTeCA) 2011, 12 | Track: State 3rd Place (3200M-2012); Indiana All Star 2012 |
| Powers, Paige | 2012 | SIM | Track | City Champion (3200M Relay-2012) |
| Salyer, Maggie | 2012 | IHM | Track | City Champion (3200M Relay-2011) |
| Sauer, Tim | 2012 | SPX | Baseball | All City (City Coaches) 2012 |
| Scheidler, Dan | 2012 | LUKE | Soccer | All-City Tournament Team 2011 |
| Siderys, Nick | 2012 | IHM | Track | City Champion (1600M Relay-2010) |
| Siegler, Lexi | 2012 | LUKE | Volleyball | All-City Tournament Team 2011 |
| Sobolewski, Kara | 2012 | MATT | Cross Country | All City (MCCGSA) 2009 |
| Sullivan, Joe | 2012 | SPX | Rugby | All State (Rugby Indiana) 2009, 10, 11, 12 |
| Tyler, Chris | 2012 | CTK | Softball | All City (MCCGSA) 2012 |
| VanVliet, Max | 2012 | SIM | Football | All City (City Coaches) 2011; All State (IFCA) 2011 |
| Wagner, Daniel | 2012 | MON | Football | All City (City Coaches) 2011 |
| Wheelock, Courtney | 2012 | CTK | Lacrosse | All State (Indiana Women’s Lacrosse Assoc.) 2012; Honorable Mention All American (USLacrosse) 2012 |
| Williams, Christian | 2012 | SJA | Golf | All City (MCCGSA) 2010 |
| Wood, Greg | 2012 | SPX | Rugby | All State (Rugby Indiana) 2009, 10, 11, 12 |
| Barnes, Stephanie | 2013 | CTK | Track | City Champ (1600M Relay & 3200M Relays-2010 & 11 | 400M & 1600M Relay-2012), Sectional Champ (3200M Relay-2011 & 12), Regional Champ (3200M Relay-2012), State Finalist (3200M Relay-2010 & 11), State 2nd Place (3200M Relay-2012) |
| Barron, Shelby | 2013 | SPX | Lacrosse | All State (IHSWLA) 2013 |
| Brown, Lauren | 2013 | CTK | Softball | All City & City-County All Star 2013 |
| Burkert, Marco | 2013 | MATT | Track | City Champ (400M-2012 & 13 | 200M & 1600M Relay-2013), Sectional & Regional Champ (400M-2013), State Finalist (400M-2013) |
| Busald, Jack | 2013 | SPX | Track | City Champ (1600M Relay & 3200M Relays-2013) |
| Bussell, Caroline | 2013 | IHM | Soccer | All City (MCCGSA) 2012 |
| Butrum, Bailey | 2013 | CTK | Softball | All City (MCCGSA) 2012 |
| Ciresi, Patrick | 2013 | CTK | Cross Country | All City 2011 & 12 |
| Collier, Marissa | 2013 | SPX | Volleyball, Basketball | VB: All City Tournament Team 2011, All City (MCCGSA) 2011 & 12, SUPERTEAM (IndyStar) 2012, All State (ICGSA) 2012 | BB: City-County All Star 2013 | City Athlete-of-the-Year (MCAA) 2013 |
| Collins, Michael | 2013 | SIM | Golf | All City 2012 |
| Dickson, Gabe | 2013 | Golf | All City 2011, 12 & 13 | |
| Doyle, Joe | 2013 | SPX | Football | All City 2012, All State 2011 & 12 |
| Dury, Rob | 2013 | IHM | Football | All City 2012, All State 2011, Indiana All Star |
| Fagan, Joe | 2013 | SPX | Football, Basketball | FB: All City, SUPERTEAM (IndyStar), All State (IFCA & AP) 2012 | BB: All City Tournament Team & City-County All Star 2013 |
| Hartley, Pete | 2013 | LUKE | Football | All City & All State (IFCA & AP) 2012 |
| Hutson, Bridget | 2013 | IHM | Cross Country | All City (MCCGSA) 2012 |
| Lowry, Annalise | 2013 | IHM | Volleyball | All City (MCCGSA) 2011, All City Tournament Team 2012 |
| Lux, Emily | 2013 | SPX | Cross Country, Track | XC: All City (MCCGSA) 2010, 11 & 12, All Sectional 2011 & 12 | Track: City Champ (3200M Relay-2011), Sectional Champ (3200M Relay-2011 & 12), Regional Champ (3200M Relay-2012), State 2nd Place (3200M Relay-2012) |
| Maexner, Nikkie | 2013 | MON | Swimming, Softball | Swim: City Champ (400y Free Relay-2012) | Softball: All City (MCCGSA) & City-County All Star 2013 |
| Mark, Sarah | 2013 | IHM | Track | City Champ (1600M Relay-2012 & 13) |
| McNulty, Emily | 2013 | MATT | Soccer | All City Tournament Team 2012 |
| Meier, Sophie | 2013 | CTK | Cross Country, Track | XC: All City 2010 | Track: City Champ (200M-2011, Long Jump-2012, 1600M Relay-2010, 11 & 13), Sectional Champ (Long Jump-2011, 12 & 13), Regional Champ (Long Jump-2012), State Finalist (1600M Relay-2010 & 12 | Long Jump-2010, 11, 12 & 13) |
| Naylor-Cook, Jackson | 2013 | IHM | Track | City Champ (3200M Relay-2013) |
| Oldiges, Kurtis | 2013 | LUKE | Track | City Champ (3200M Relay-2013) |
| Paras, Morgan | 2013 | LUKE | Tennis | All District (IHSTeCA) & Indiana All Star 2013 |
| Parker, Hannah | 2013 | CTK | Track | City Champ (High Jump-2013), State Finalist (High Jump-2013) |
| Parsons, Sean | 2013 | LAW | Golf | All City 2011 |
| Perry, Ashlyn | 2013 | SIM | Soccer | All City Tournament Team & All City (MCCGSA) 2011 & 12 |
| Pluckebaum, Andrew | 2013 | LUKE | Baseball | All City Tournament Team 2012 & All City (Coaches) 2013 |
| Rhodes, Dustin | 2013 | SIM | Lacrosse | All State (IHSLA) 2013 |
| Schellinger, Zack | 2013 | IHM | Football | All State & SUPERTEAM (IndyStar) 2012 |
| Schroeder, Ellen | 2013 | SIM | Volleyball | All City Tournament Team & All City (MCCGSA) 2012 |
| Sergi, Marianne | 2013 | MATT | Soccer, Swimming, Tennis | Soccer: All City Tournament Team & All City (MCCGSA) 2011 & 12 | Swim: City Champ (50y & 100y Free-2011 | 400y Free Relay-2012) | Tennis: City Champ (#2 Singles) & Indiana All Star 2013 |
| Summerlin, Sammie | 2013 | STA | Golf | All City (MCCGSA) & All Sectional 2012 |
| Treesh, Colleen | 2013 | SIM | Swimming | City Champ (Diving-2010) |
| Weimer, Michael | 2013 | CTK | Rugby | All State 2013 |
| Wessel, Elaine | 2013 | SIM | Track | City Champ (3200M Relay-2011 & 12 | 1600M Relay-2013), Sectional Champ (3200M Relay-2011), State Finalist (3200M Relay-2011) |
| Annee, Michael | 2014 | Football | All City (City Coaches) 2013, All State (IFCA) 2012, 13 | |
| Barnes, Paige | 2014 | Softball | All City (MCCGSA) 2014 | |
| Bennett, Justin | 2014 | Football | All City (City Coaches) 2013 | |
| Collier, Dean | 2014 | Soccer | All City 2013 | |
| Crone, Erin | 2014 | X-Country, Track | Cross-Country: All City (MCCGSA) 2011, 12; City Champion 2013; All Sectional 2012 & 13, All Regional 2013 | Track: City Champion (3200M & 3200M Relay-2012 & 13 and 800M & 1600M-2014); State Finalist (1600M-2012, 14, 3200M Relay-2013, and 800M-2014) | |
| Doucleff, David | 2014 | Rugby | All State 2014 | |
| Gardner, Hannah | 2014 | Basketball, Volleyball | Basketball: All City (MCCGSA) 2012, 13, 14; All-City Tournament Team 2013, 14 | Volleyball: All City (MCCGSA) 2014; All-City Tournament Team 2014 | City Athlete of the Year (MCCGSA & MCAA) 2014 | Indy Star Sportswoman of the Year 2014 | |
| Gore, Liz | 2014 | Swimming | City Champion (400y Free Relay-2012) | |
| Hill, Henry | 2014 | Football | All City (City Coaches) 2013; All State (IFCA) 2012, 13 | |
| Hoffman, Joe | 2014 | Soccer | All-City Tournament Team 2013 | |
| Jackson, Stan | 2014 | Football | All City (City Coaches) 2013; All State (IFCA) 2013 | |
| Joyce, Shea | 2014 | Golf | All City (MCCGSA) 2012, 13 & All Sectional 2012 | |
| Kilbane, Mary | 2014 | Volleyball | All City (MCCGSA) 2011, 12; All-City Tournament Team 2011, 12 | |
| Kimack, Alex | 2014 | Football | All City (City Coaches) 2013; Indiana All Star | |
| Kirkhoff, Krissy | 2014 | Soccer | All City (MCCGSA) 2010, 11, 12, 13; All-City Tournament Team 2011, 12; All District 2011, 12, 13; All State (ICGSA) 2013 | |
| Lechner, Quinn | 2014 | Soccer | All-City Tournament Team 2012, All City 2013 | |
| Lorah, Matt | 2014 | Golf | All City 2013, 14 | |
| McHugh, Michael | 2014 | Football | All City (City Coaches) 2013 | |
| Metzger, Zach | 2014 | Track | City Champion (Pole Vault-2012 & 13) | |
| Ney, Jake | 2014 | Rugby | All State 2014 | |
| Nightingale, Andrew | 2014 | Tennis | All District 2013 | |
| Pruitt, Danny | 2014 | Tennis | All District 2013 | |
| Reynolds, Chad | 2014 | Swimming | City Champion (200y Free Relay-2012) | |
| Sadler, Chase | 2014 | Football | All State (AP) 2013 | |
| Schapker, Michael | 2014 | Baseball | All City (City Coaches) 2014 | |
| Schueth, Stephen | 2014 | Golf | All City 2014 | |
| Taylor, Max | 2014 | Baseball | All City (City Coaches) 2013 | |
| Thornburg, Will | 2014 | Football | All City (City Coaches) 2012 | |
| Turchetti, Ruby | 2014 | Golf | All City (MCCGSA) 2012, 13, All Sectional 2013 | |
| Allen, Rachel | 2015 | Lacrosse | All State (INGLA) 2015 | |
| Ball, Brian | 2015 | Football, Baseball | Football: All City (Coaches) 2014 Baseball: All City (City Coaches) 2013, 2014 & All-City Tournament Team 2013 & 14 City Athlete of the Year (MCAA) 2015 | |
| Barnes, Joe | 2015 | Swimming | City Champion: 200y Free-2011 & 14, 200y Free Relay-2012 & 14, 100y Free-2013, 100y Butterfly-2014, 400y Free Relay-2014 | |
| Bunnell, Marlin | 2015 | Football, Track | Football: All City (Coaches) 2014, All State (IFCA) 2014 Track: City Champion: 1600M Relay-2013 | |
| Burton, Ashleigh | 2015 | Basketball | All-City Tournament Team 2015 | |
| Casey, Sean | 2015 | Baseball | All-City Tournament Team 2014, All City (Coaches) 2015 | |
| Collins, Lauren | 2015 | Soccer | All City (MCCGSA) 2014 | |
| Dury, Grace | 2015 | Basketball | All City (MCCGSA) & All-City Tournament Team 2015 | |
| Eisgruber, Lucy | 2015 | Cross Country, Track | Cross Country:All City 2013 Track: City Champion {3200M Relay-2013}; State Finalist {3200M Relay-2013} | |
| Fagan, Mary Claire | 2015 | Cross Country, Track | Cross Country: All City (MCCGSA) 2011, 12; All Sectional 2012 Track: City Champion: 3200M Relay-2013; State Finalist: 3200M Relay-2013 | |
| Foster, Sydney | 2015 | Golf, Swimming | Golf: All City (MCCGSA) 2012, 14 Swimming: City Champion: 100y Breast-2012, 13 & 400y Free Relay-2012 | |
| Groves, Nick | 2015 | Lacrosse | All State (IHSLA) 2015 | |
| Haimbaugh, Charlie | 2015 | Soccer | All-City Tournament Team 2013; All City 2013 | |
| Hannon, Brian | 2015 | Rugby | All State 2014 & 15; All American 2013, 14 & 15; Youth Olympic Participant 2014 | |
| Hepp, Brooks | 2015 | Football, Baseball | Football: All City (Coaches) 2014 Baseball: All City (Coaches) & All City Tournament Team 2015 | |
| Kelly, Jacob | 2015 | Track | City Champion: 1600M Relay-2013, 14 & 3200M Relay-2013; State Finalist: 1600M Relay-2013 | |
| Kelly-Hooks, Kennedy | 2015 | Track | City & Sectional Champion, 1600M Relay-2015 | |
| LaRose, Anthony | 2015 | Football | All City (Coaches) 2014 | |
| Logan, Anna | 2015 | Volleyball, Basketball, Track | Volleyball: All-City Tournament Team 2012, 13, 14; All City (MCCGSA) 2012, 13, 14; All State (ICGSA) 2012, 14; SUPERTEAM (IndyStar) 2012 Basketball: All-City Tournament Team 2012, 13, 14, 15; All City 2015; City-County All Star 2015 Track: City Champion – Discus-2012, 13, 15; Sectional & Regional Champion- Discus-2015; State Finalist-Discus-2013, 15; City Athlete of the Year (MCCGSA & MCAA) 2015 | |
| McCann, Matt | 2015 | Football | All City (City Coaches) 2013 & 14; All State (IFCA) 2013 | |
| Nondorf, Luke | 2015 | Swimming | City Champion-200y Free Relay-2012, 100y Breastroke-2013 & 14, 50y Freestyle-2014, 200y Medley Relay-2014, 400y Free Relay-2014; Sectional Champion & State Qualifier-100y Breaststroke-2015 | |
| Schrader, Noah | 2015 | Wrestling, Rugby | Wrestling: City, Sectional & Regional Champion – 195 lbs-2014; State Qualifier-195 lbs-2014; Rugby: All State & All American 2014 & 15 | |
| Smith, Eric | 2015 | Football | All City (Coaches) 2014, All State (AP & IFCA) 2014 | |
| Sullivan, Sean | 2015 | Cross Country | All City 2013 | |
| Weimer, Drew | 2015 | Rugby | All State 2014 & 15 | |
| White, Maddie | 2015 | Lacrosse | All State (IHSWLA) 2014 | |
| Winternheimer, Susie | 2015 | Tennis | All District 2015 | |
| Wuensch, Emily | 2015 | Volleyball | All City 2014, All City Tourney Team 2014 |
2016 Honorees
| Name | Year | Sport(s) | Award |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aycock, Ashlin | 2016 | Basketball | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA), City County All Star 2016 | |||
| Barnes, Alex | 2016 | Softball | Details |
| All City(MCCGSA), 2015, 2016 | |||
| Behringer, Evan | 2016 | Wrestling | Details |
| City Champion (138 lb) | |||
| Brogan, Patrick | 2016 | Soccer | Details |
| All City (Coaches) & All City Tournament Team 2014 | |||
| Casey, Nick | 2016 | Baseball | Details |
| All City Tournament Team 2015 | |||
| Chapman, Erin | 2016 | Track | Details |
| City Champion (1600M Relay-2015, 16), Sectional Champion (1600M Relay-2015), State Finalist (1600M Relay & 3200M Relay-2016) | |||
| Chavis, John | 2016 | Track | Details |
| City Champion (100M-2016, 400M-2016, 1600M Relay-2014, ’15, ’16); Sectional Champion (400M-2015, ’16); Regional Champion (400M-2016); State Finalist (400M-2015, 16; 1600M Relay-2014, ’15, ’16); Indiana All Star 2016 | |||
| Coan, Becca | 2016 | Track | Details |
| City Champion (1600M Relay-2013 & ’15), Sectional Champion (1600M Relay-2015), State Finalist (400M-2015; 1600M Relay & 3200M Relay-2016) | |||
| Ernst, Teresa | 2016 | Track | Details |
| City Champion (300M Hurdles-2013, 1600M Relay-2016), State Finalist (300M Hurdles-2015) | |||
| Fehribach, Anna | 2016 | Volleyball | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA) & All-City Tournament Team 2014, ’15; Indiana All Star 2015 | |||
| Gaynor, Karsyn | 2016 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All State (INGLA) 2016 | |||
| Godlevske, Danny | 2016 | Football | Details |
| All City, All State (IFCA & AP), All American Bowl 2015 | |||
| Grote, Nick | 2016 | Football, track | Details |
| Football:All City 2015; Track: City Champion (High Jump 2015 & 16, 1600M Relay 2015 & 300M Hurdles 2016), Sectional Champ (HJ & 1600M Relay 2015 & 16), State Finalist (1600M Relay 2016) | |||
| Guymon, Sam | 2016 | Basketball | Details |
| All City (City Coaches); City-County All Star 2016 | |||
| Hedlund, Jenna | 2016 | CrossCountry, Track | Details |
| XC: All City 2013; Track: City Champion (3200M Relay-2013, 14); State Finalist (3200M Relay-2013) | |||
| Hirschfeld, Doug | 2016 | Swimming | Details |
| City Champion (200y Free Relay-2012) | |||
| Kimack, Jenna | 2016 | Track | Details |
| City & Sectional Champion (300M Hurdles-2014); City Champion (400M Relay-2016) | |||
| Kobets, Caleb | 2016 | Soccer | Details |
| All City (Coaches) 2015 | |||
| Lubbers, Anna | 2016 | Volleyball | Details |
| All City 2014, All City Tourney Team 2014 | |||
| Mack, Jacob | 2016 | Track | Details |
| City Champion (Pole Vault-2016) | |||
| Mahin, Payton | 2016 | Soccer | Details |
| All City (Coaches) 2014; All City Tournament Team 2015 | |||
| Murray, Maria | 2016 | Track | Details |
| City Champion (High Jump-2014, 15, 16; 400M Relay-2016), Sectional Champion (HJ-2015, 16); Regional Champion (HJ-2016); State Finalist ({HJ-2015, 16); Indiana All Star 2016 | |||
| O’Hara, Kevin | 2016 | Rugby | Details |
| All State 2015 | |||
| Oldiges, Johnathan | 2016 | Cross Country | Details |
| All City 2016 | |||
| Pruitt, John | 2016 | Golf | Details |
| All Sectional 2016 | |||
| Ruby, Luca | 2016 | Soccer | Details |
| All City (Coaches) 2015 | |||
| Sammy, Robert | 2016 | Track | Details |
| City & Sectional Champion (1600M Relay 2016), State Finalist (1600M Relay-2016) | |||
| Saunders, Pete | 2016 | Football, Track | Details |
| Football: All State (AP) 2015; Track: City Champion (Long Jump-2016, 1600M Relay-2014, 15, 16); State Finalist (1600M Relay-2015) | |||
| Schilling, Emma | 2016 | Soccer | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA) 2014, ’15 | |||
| Scheer, Austin | 2016 | Swimming | Details |
| City Champion (200y Medley Relay-2014; 400y Free Relay-2014, 15; 200y IM-2015, 500y Free-2015, 200y Free Relay-2015) | |||
| Schrader, Zoe | 2016 | Track | Details |
| City Champion (Pole Vault-2013, 15, 16), Sectional Champion (Pole Vault-2016), State Finalist (PV-2015, 16) | |||
| Sexauer, Charlie | 2016 | Football | Details |
| All State (IFCA) 2015 | |||
| Sowinski, Patrick | 2016 | Football, Baseball | Details |
| Football: All State (IFCA & AP) 2015; Baseball: All City (City Coaches) 2016 & All-City Tournament Team 2015, 16 | |||
| Skripsky, Rosemary | 2016 | Track | Details |
| City & Sectional Champion (Shot Put-2015, 16); State Finalist (Shot Put-2016); Indiana All Star 2016 | |||
| Summerlin, John | 2016 | Golf | Details |
| All City 2014, 15, 16; All Sectional 2016 | |||
| Thomas, Griffin | 2016 | Golf | Details |
| All City 2015, 16 | |||
| Toetz, Victoria | 2016 | Softball | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA) 2014, 15 | |||
| Treesh, Peter | 2016 | Baseball | Details |
| All City (City Coaches) 2016 | |||
| Walker, Blake | 2016 | Baseball | Details |
| All-City Tournament Team 2016 |
2017 Honorees
| Name | Year | Sport(s) | Award |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annee, Matthew | 2017 | Football | Details |
| All Conference 2016 | |||
| Barnes, Emily | 2017 | Tennis | Details |
| North South All Star 2017 | |||
| Barnes, Mary | 2017 | Swimming | Details |
| City Champion ({100y Butterfly-2014, 15, 200y Free Relay-2014, 15, 16 and 400y Free Relay-2014); Conference Champions (100y Breaststroke & Butterfly-2017) | |||
| Boyle, Sam | 2017 | Golf | Details |
| All City 2016 | |||
| Breitbach, Tayra | 2017 | Basketball | Details |
| All City Tournament Team 2016, 2017; All Conference 2017; All City (MCCGSA) 2017 | |||
| Burns, Mary | 2017 | Track, Soccer | Details |
| City Champion (3200M Relay-2014); Soccer: l City (MCCGSA) 2014, 16; All City Tournament Team 2016 | |||
| Christmann, Jake | 2017 | Rugby | Details |
| All State 2016, 17; All American 2017 | |||
| Coleman, Gabe | 2017 | Football | Details |
| All State (IFCA & AP) 2015; All Conference 2016 | |||
| Crawford, Jax | 2017 | Cross Country | Details |
| All City 2016 | |||
| Dietrick, John | 2017 | Tennis | Details |
| All District (IHSTeCA) 2016 | |||
| Dochee, Jalen | 2017 | Track | Details |
| Sectional Champion (Pole Vault) 2016, 17; State Finalist (PV) 2017 | |||
| Dury, Billy | 2017 | Football | Details |
| All Conference 2016 | |||
| Fischer, Zach | 2017 | Tennis | Details |
| All District (IHSTeCA) 2016 | |||
| Giudice, Ellen | 2017 | Tennis | Details |
| North South All Star 2017 | |||
| Hirschfeld, Thomas | 2017 | Swimming | Details |
| City Champion (200y Medley Relay-2014; 400y Freestyle Relay-2014, 15; & 200y Free Relay-2015, 16) | |||
| Hopkins, Parker | 2017 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2017 | |||
| Hurley, John | 2017 | Swimming | Details |
| City Champion (200y Free Relay-2015, 16 & 400y Freestyle Relay-2015) | |||
| Hurley, Sean | 2017 | Cross Country | Details |
| All City 2016 | |||
| Eisgruber, Josef | 2017 | Wrestling | Details |
| City Champion 2014 (106 lbs.) | |||
| Jacobson, Sarah | 2017 | Soccer | Details |
| All City 2015; All Conference 2016 | |||
| Jacquay, Delaney | 2017 | Crss Country, Track | Details |
| All City 2015, 16; Track: City Champion (3200M Relay-2014, 15; 1600M Relay-2017); Sectional Champion (3200M Relay-2015); State Finalist (3200M Relay-2016; 1600M Relay-2017) | |||
| Kassenbrock, Maggie | 2017 | Volleyball, Softabll | Details |
| All City, All Conference 2016; Softball: All City (MCCGSA) 2014, 15, 16, 17; All City Tournament Team 2016 | |||
| Kontor, Frankie | 2017 | Basketball, Softball | Details |
| All Conference 2017; Softball: All City (MCCGSA) 2016, 17 | |||
| Manuszak, Ethan | 2017 | Soccer | Details |
| All City (Coaches), All Conference 2016 | |||
| Marsh, David | 2017 | Football | Details |
| All City, All Conference, All State (IFCA) 2016 | |||
| Ney, Max | 2017 | Rugby | Details |
| All American 2017 | |||
| Nondorf, Danielle | 2017 | Swimming | Details |
| City Champion ({200y Freestyle Relay-2014, 15, 16 and 400y Freestyle Relay-2014) | |||
| O’Brien, Arie | 2017 | Track | Details |
| City Champion (3200M Relay-2014) | |||
| Park, Abby | 2017 | Swimming | Details |
| City Champion {200y Freestyle Relay and 400y Freestyle Relay-2014} | |||
| Pedtke, Jarron | 2017 | Rugby | Details |
| AAll State 2017 | |||
| Perry, Katie | 2017 | Soccer | Details |
| All City 2015, 16; All City Tournament Team 2016; All Conference 2016 | |||
| Petrakopoulos, Jonas | 2017 | Rugby | Details |
| All American 2016, 17; All State 2017 | |||
| Sammy, Brandon | 2017 | Track | Details |
| City & Sectional Champion (1600M Relay-2016; 200M-2017); Sectional Champion (200M-2017); State Finalist (1600M Relay-2016) | |||
| Solomon, Ben | 2017 | Football | Details |
| All Conference, All State (IFCA) 2016 | |||
| Stiver, Jarrod | 2017 | Track | Details |
| City Champion {1600M Relay-2014, 15}; State Finalist 2015 | |||
| Wann, Maddie | 2017 | Golf | Details |
| All City 2015, 16 | |||
| Williams, Nick | 2017 | Swimming,Golf | Details |
| City Champion (200y Free Relay-2016); Golf: All City 2014, 15, 16, 17; Conference & Sectional Medalist 2017; All Regional 2015, 17; State Finalist 2015, 17 |
2018 Honorees
| Name | Year | Sport(s) | Award |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joey Annee | 2018 | Football | Details |
|
All City (Coaches) 2017 |
|||
| Alyssa Behringer | 2018 | X-Country | Details |
| All City 2015 | |||
| Jimmy Boso | 2018 | Football | Details |
| All Conference 2017; All City (Coaches) 2017 | |||
| Ryan Burns | 2018 | Baseball | Details |
| All City (Coaches) 2018 | |||
| Katie Duggan | 2018 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2018 | |||
| Maeve Flynn | 2018 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2017 | |||
| Jess Friederick | 2018 | Soccer | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA) 2017 | |||
| Patrick Guymon | 2018 | Golf | Details |
| All City 2017, 18 | |||
| Patrick Haimbaugh | 2018 | Volleyball | Details |
| All Conference 2017 | |||
| Haylie Hall | 2018 | Volleyball | Details |
| All City Tournament Team 2017 | |||
| David Hannon | 2018 | Rugby | Details |
| All State 2015; All American 2015 | |||
| Joe Keefe | 2018 | Soccer | Details |
| All City (Coaches) 2015; All City Tournament Team 2015 | |||
| Jackson Kehrer | 2018 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2017 | |||
| Will Kellison | 2018 | Football | Details |
| All Conference 2017; All City (Coaches) 2017; SUPERTEAM 2017; All State (IFCA) 2016, 17 City Athlete of the Year (MCAA) 2018 | |||
| Emma Kennedy | 2018 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2017, 18; All State (INGLA) 2017, 18; All American (USL) 2018 | |||
| Nathan Kolbus | 2018 | X-Country, Track | Details |
|
X-Country: All Conference 2017; All City 2015, 16, 17 Track: City Champion (3200M-2017) |
|||
| T.J. Mann | 2018 | Baseball | Details |
| All Conference 2017, 18; All City Tournament Team 2018 | |||
| Sarah Mastrian | 2018 | Softball | Details |
| All Conference 2017, 18; All City (MCCGSA) 2015, 16, 18; All City Tournament Team 2016 | |||
| Kevin McNelis | 2018 | Football | Details |
| All Conference 2017 | |||
| Payten Morris | 2018 | Volleyball | Details |
| All Conference, All City (MCCGSA), All City Tournament Team, All District 2017 | |||
| Bridget Nash | 2018 | Soccer | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA) 2017 | |||
| Christine Oppold | 2018 | Softball | Details |
| All Conference 2017, 18; All City (MCCGSA) 2015, 16, 17, 18 | |||
| Jordan Ortman | 2018 | Swimming, Track | Details |
|
Swimming: City Champion (200y Freestyle Relay-2015, 16) Track: City Champion (Discus-2017, 18) |
|||
| Andrew Penry | 2018 | Volleyball | Details |
| All Conference 2017, 18; All State (IBVCA) 2018 | |||
| Elena Redmond | 2018 | Volleyball | Details |
| All Conference 2016, 17; All City (MCCGSA) 2015, 16, 17; All City Tournament Team 2015, 17; All District 2017, All State (ICGSA & IHSVCA) 2017; Indiana All Star 2017 | |||
| Abby Saunders | 2018 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2017, 18 | |||
| Marcos Schmitz | 2018 | Soccer | Details |
| All City (Coaches) 2016 | |||
| Sophie Sergi | 2018 | Soccer, Tennis | Details |
|
Soccer: All Conference 2017; All City (MCCGSA) 2015, 16, 17; All Tournament Team 2016, 17 Tennis: All District (IHSTeCA) 2018 |
|||
| Abby Teed | 2018 | X-Country, Swimming | Details |
|
X-Country: All City 2014, 16, 17 Swimming: City Champion (200y Freestyle Relay-2014, 15, 16 and 400y Freestyle Relay-2014) |
|||
| Tyler Thompson | 2018 | Swimming | Details |
| Conference Champion (200y Freestyle-2017 and 100y Fly-2018); City Champion (100y Fly-2017; 200y Freestyle-2015, 16; 200y Freestyle Relay-2015, 16 and 400y Freestyle Relay-2015) | |||
| Lindsey Traub | 2018 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2017, 18; All State (INGLA) 2018 | |||
| Sara Wallander | 2018 | Soccer, Lacrosse | Details |
|
Soccer: All City (MCCGSA) 2015, 16 Lacrosse:All Conference 2017, 18 |
|||
| Maddie Walters | 2018 | Soccer | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA) 2017; All City Tournament Team 2015, 17 | |||
| Sam White | 2018 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2018 |
Class of 2019 Honorees
| Name | Year | Sport(s) | Award |
|---|---|---|---|
| Beth Barnes | 2019 | Volleyball, Track | Details |
|
VOLLEYBALL: All District (IHSVCA) 2018 |
|||
| Kate Bosley | 2019 | Volleyball | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA) 2018; All Tournament Team 2018; All State (ICGSA) 2018 | |||
| Izzy Corns | 2019 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2019 | |||
| Katie Dietrick | 2019 | Cross Country, Track | Details |
|
CROSS COUNTRY: All City & All Sectional 2015, 16; All Conference 2016 TRACK: City Champion (1600M Relay-2016, 17, 18, 19; 200 & 400-2017, 18, 19), Conference Champion (400M-2018; 1600M Relay-2018, 19); Sectional Champion (1600M Relay-2019),State Finalist (3200M Relay-2016; 1600M Relay-2016, 17, 18, 19; 400-2017) |
|||
| Oskar Eisgruber | 2019 | Diving | Details |
| Conference Champion 2017, 18, 19; City Champion 2017, 18; State Finalist 2019 | |||
| Zack Evans | 2019 | Wrestling | Details |
| City Champion (Heavyweight-2016) | |||
| Will Freiburger | 2019 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2018, 2019 | |||
| Rebekkaha Guess | 2019 | Soccer, Track | Details |
|
SOCCER: All City (MCCGSA) 2017, 18; All Tournament Team 2017, 2018 TRACK: City Champion (400M Relay-2016, 18) |
|||
| Alysa Guffey | 2019 | Tennis | Details |
| All District (IHSTeCA) 2017, 18, 19; North South All Star 2019 | |||
| Sydney Hamilton-Ragsdale | 2019 | Track | Details |
| City Champion (100M-2016 & 400M Relay-2016, 18), Sectional Champion (200M-2016); State Finalist (1600M Relay-2018) | |||
| Elizabeth Jacobson | 2019 | Soccer | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA) 2015, 16, 17, 18; All Tournament Team 2015, 16, 17, 18; All Conference 2016, 17, 18; All District (ISCA) 2017, 2018; All State (ISCA) 2018 | |||
| Audrey Jaeger | 2019 | Track | Details |
| City Champion (Long Jump-2017) | |||
| Cierra Landers | 2019 | Softball | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA) 2019; All Conference 2019 | |||
| Cooper Lewis | 2019 | Basketball | Details |
| All Conference 2019 | |||
| Will Meyer | 2019 | Football | Details |
| All Conference 2018; All City (Coaches) 2018 | |||
| Mark Nondorf | 2019 | Football, Volleyball | Details |
|
FOOTBALL: All Conference 2017, 18; All City (Coaches) 2017, 18; All State (IFCA) 2018 VOLLEYBALL: All Conference 2019 |
|||
| Eric Osborn | 2019 | Football | Details |
| All Conference 2018 | |||
| Colette Pauta | 2019 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2019 | |||
| Adam Pemberton | 2019 | Track | Details |
| City Champion (Shot Put-2019) | |||
| Jack Phelps | 2019 | Baseball | Details |
| All Conference 2019; All City (Coaches) 2019; All Tournament Team 2019 | |||
| Ben Schrage | 2019 | Golf | Details |
| All City | |||
| Ryan Seymour | 2019 | Wrestling | Details |
| Conference Champion (120 lbs-2016) | |||
| Jackson Sherby | 2019 | Rugby | Details |
| All State | |||
| David Whittemore | 2019 | Football | Details |
| All Conference 2018; All State (IFCA) 2018 | |||
| Claire Williams | 2019 | Golf, Tennis | Details |
|
GOLF: All City 2016, 2018 TENNIS: All District (IHSTeCA) 2018; North South All Star 2019 |
Class of 2020
| Name | Year | Sport(s) | Award |
|---|---|---|---|
| George Assalley | 2020 | Football | Details |
|
All Conference, All City 2019 |
|||
| Reagan Behringer | 2020 | Softball | Details |
| All City 2020 | |||
| Mary Borchers | 2020 | Basketball | Details |
| All City 2018 | |||
| DeeDee Caskey | 2020 | Softball | Details |
| All Conference, All City (MCCGSA) 2018, 19, 20 | |||
| Kyle Cheek | 2020 | Football | Details |
| All Conference, All City 2019 | |||
| Ethan Clapacs | 2020 | Cross Country | Details |
| All City 2018, 19; All Sectional 2019 | |||
| Ruby Countryman | 2020 | Volleyball | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA) 2019; All City Tournament Team 2018, 19; All Conference 2019; All District (IHSVCA) 2018, 19 | |||
| Amelia Dessauer | 2020 | Track | Details |
| City Champion (Pole Vault & 1600M Relay) 2019 | |||
| Martin Duffy | 2020 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2019 | |||
| Michael Duffy | 2020 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference & All State 2019 | |||
| George Forsee | 2020 | Soccer | Details |
| All Conference 2017, All City (Coaches) 2017, 19 | |||
| Charlie Jacoba | 2020 | Cross Country | Details |
| All City 2018, 19 | |||
| Patrick Mastrian | 2020 | Football, Baseball | Details |
|
Football: All Conference 2018, 19; All City 2019; All State (IFCA) 2019 |
|||
| Sarah Meek | 2020 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2018, 19; All State (INGLA) 2019 | |||
| Holli Parker | 2020 | Track, Soccer | Details |
|
Track: Conference Champion (HJ) 2018 |
|||
| Erika Pemberton | 2020 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2019 | |||
| Anna Pruitt | 2020 | Soccer, Softball | Details |
|
SOCCER: All City (MCCGSA) 2018, 19; All City Tournament Team 2018 19; All Conference 2019 SOFTBALL: All City (MCCGSA) 2018, 19, 20; All City Tournament Team 2019; All Circle City Conference 2018, 19 |
|||
| Edreece Redmond | 2020 | Basketball | Details |
| All Conference 2019, 20; All City Tournament Team, All City (City Coaches) 2020 | |||
| Abigail Reed | 2020 | Softball | Details |
| All City 2020 | |||
| Curtis Richardson | 2020 | Track | Details |
| Conference Champion (100M & 200M), State Finalist (100M) 2019 | |||
| Maggie Schaffer | 2020 | Golf | Details |
| All City 2016, 19; City Medalist 2017, 18; Conference Medalist 2016, All Conference 2017, 18, 19; Sectional Medalist 2016, All Sectional 2017, 18, 19; Regional Medalist 2018; State Finalist 2017, 18; All State 2019 | |||
| Wyatt Schrader | 2020 | Football, Rugby | Details |
|
Football: All Conference, All City(Coaches) 2018, 19 Rugby: All State 2019 |
|||
| Max Schrage | 2020 | Football | Details |
| All Conference 2019 | |||
| Joseph Solomon | 2020 | Football | Details |
| All Conference, All City(Coaches), All State (AP, Top 50 IFCA) 2018, 19; SUPERTEAM 2019 | |||
| Sydney Sorenson | 2020 | Tennis | Details |
| North South All Star (ICGSA) 2020 | |||
| Andrew Sowinski | 2020 | Baseball, Football | Details |
|
BASEBALL: All Conference, All City (City Coaches), All City Tournament Team 2019 FOOTBALL: All Conference, All State (IFCA) 2018, 19; SUPERTEAM 2019 |
|||
| Miranda Stickel | 2020 | Track | Details |
| City Champion (1600M Relay) 2017, 18; Conference Champion (1600M Relay) 2018, 19; State Finalist (1600M Relay) 2017 | |||
| Daylen Taylor | 2020 | Football | Details |
| All Conference 2017, 18, 19; All City(Coaches), All State (IFCA) 2018, 19; SUPERTEAM 2019 | |||
| Caroline Thompson | 2020 | Softball | Details |
| All City 2020 | |||
| Abby Underwood | 2020 | Soccer | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA), All City Tournament Team 2019 | |||
| Grace Underwood | 2020 | Soccer | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA), All City Tournament Team 2018, 19 | |||
| Anna Wuensch | 2020 | Volleyball | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA) 2016, 18, 19; All City Tournament Team 2019; All Conference 2018, 19; All District 2018, 19; All State (ICGSA) 2017, 18 | |||
| Jacob Zurawski | 2020 | Tennis | Details |
| All District 2019 |
Class of 2021
| Name | Year | Sport(s) | Award |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sam Annakin | 2021 | Tennis | Details |
| All District 2019 | |||
| Danny Bardol | 2021 | Soccer | Details |
| All City 2020 | |||
| Jackson Bolen | 2021 | Track | Details |
| Conference Champion {100M, 200M, 400M Relay}, City Champion {200M, 400M Relay, 1600M Relay}, Sectional Champion {100M, 200M, 1600M Relay}, Regional Champion {400M Relay}, State Qualifier {100M, 400M Relay} 2021 | |||
| Dakota Boyd | 2021 | Wrestling | Details |
| Conference Champion {220 lbs.} 2021 | |||
| Joe Calvert | 2021 | Football | Details |
| All Conference 2020 | |||
| Noah Carter | 2021 | Basketball | Details |
| All Conference 2021 | |||
| Megan Chamberlain | 2021 | Softball | Details |
| All City 2021 | |||
| Thomas Coleman | 2021 | Football, Track | Details |
|
FOOTBALL: All Conference, All City, All State, SUPERTEAM 2020 TRACK: City & Conference Champion {400M Relay, 1600M Relay}, Regional Champion {400M Relay}, State Qualifier {400M Relay & 1600M Relay} 2021 |
|||
| Matthew Coons | 2021 | Football, Track | Details |
|
FOOTBALL: All Conference, All State 2020 TRACK: City & Conference Champion {400M Relay}, City Champion {LJ}, Regional Champion {400M Relay}, State Qualifier {400M Relay} 2021 |
|||
| Chelsea DeVettori | 2021 | Soccer | Details |
| All Conference, All City (MCCGSA), All City Tournament Team 2018, 19, 20; All District 2019 | |||
| Sally Dilts | 2021 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2021 | |||
| David Harless | 2021 | Soccer | Details |
| All City 2018, 19, 20; All Conference 2019, 2020 | |||
| Kyle Haslett | 2021 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2021 | |||
| Renee Jessee | 2021 | Golf | Details |
| All City 2020 | |||
| Will Johnson | 2021 | Soccer, Track | Details |
|
SOCCER: All Conference 2020 TRACK: Conference Champion {1600M Relay}, City Champion {3200M Relay} 2021 |
|||
| Ellen Keefe | 2021 | Volleyball | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA) 2019, 20, All Conference 2020 | |||
| Brady Kinnett | 2021 | Football, Baseball | Details |
|
FOOTBALL: All Conference, All City, All State 2020 BASEBALL: All Conference, All City 2021 |
|||
| Emily Loiselle | 2021 | Cross Country, Track, Swimming | Details |
|
CROSS COUNTRY: All Conference, All City, All Sectional, All Regional 2019, 20; All Semi-State 2019 TRACK: City & Conference Champion {3200M Relay, 800M}, Sectional & Regional Champion {3200M Relay}, Sectional Champion {1600M}, State Finalist {3200M Relay & 1600M} 2021 SWIMMING: Conference Champion {100y Butterfly} 2020; City Champion {50y Free, 100y Fly} 2020 |
|||
| Will Mason | 2021 | Football | Details |
| All Conference 2019 | |||
| Moira McGinley | 2021 | Basketball | Details |
|
All City (MCCGSA) & All Conference (coaches) 2018, 19, 20, 21; All City Tournament Team 2020, 21
Female City Athlete of the Year {MCCGSA & MCAA}2021 |
|||
| Andre Moore | 2021 | Track | Details |
| City, Conference & Regional Champion {400M Relay}, State Qualifier {400M Relay} 2021 | |||
| Abby Murray | 2021 | Volleyball | Details |
| All City 2020 | |||
| Logan O’Brien | 2021 | Football | Details |
| All Conference 2019, 20 | |||
| Zakia Rasheed | 2021 | Basketball | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA) & All Conference (coaches) 2019, 20, 21; All City Tournament Team 2020, 21; All State 2021 | |||
| Audrey Russell | 2021 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2021 | |||
| Sofi Schmitz | 2021 | Swimming | Details |
| City Champion {100y Backstroke} 2017 | |||
| Matthew Semler | 2021 | Golf | Details |
| State Finalist 2018, All City 2019, 21 | |||
| Lanie Tarowsky | 2021 | Golf | Details |
| All City 2020 | |||
| Owen Teed | 2021 | Cross Country | Details |
| All Conference, All City, All Sectional 2019 | |||
| Andrew Thrasher | 2021 | Track | Details |
| City Champion {3200M Relay} 2021 | |||
| Jack Woodcock | 2021 | Football, Wrestling | Details |
|
FOOTBALL: All Conference, All City, All State 2020 WRESTLING: Conference Champion {Heavyweight} 2021 |
Class of 2022
| Name | Year | Sport(s) | Award |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grace Adams | 2022 | Soccer, Basketball | Details |
|
SOCCER: All City (MCCGSA) 2019, 20, 21; All Conference 2020, 21; All City Tournament Team 2021
|
|||
| Jack Annee | 2022 | Football, Baseball | Details |
|
FOOTBALL: All Conference 2021 BASEBALL: All Conference 2021, 22, All City 2021 |
|||
| Brady Armstrong | 2022 | Soccer | Details |
| All Conference 2020 | |||
| Samantha Ball | 2022 | Volleyball | Details |
| All City Tournament Team 2020, 21; All City 2021 | |||
| Nolan Bosley | 2022 | Volleyball | Details |
| All Conference, All State 2021, 22 | |||
| Brady Braun | 2022 | Football | Details |
| All City 2020, 21; All Conference 2021; Under Armor All American 2021 | |||
| Nadia Brehm | 2022 | Golf | Details |
| All City 2021, All Conference 2020, 21 | |||
| Eli Bustamante | 2022 | Wrestling | Details |
| City Champion {152 lbs.} 2020, 21, Sectional Champion {152 lbs.} 2021, 22 | |||
| Kate Caskey | 2022 | Softball, Golf | Details |
|
GOLF: All City 2021 SOFTBALL: All City 2021, 22; All City Tournament Team 2022; All Conference 2022 |
|||
| Hannah Coffel | 2022 | Softball | Details |
| All City 2021, 22; All Conference 2021, 22; All City Tournament Team 2022 | |||
| Patrick Countryman | 2022 | Football, Swimming | Details |
|
FOOTBALL: All Conference 2021 SWIMMING: City Champion {200y Medley Relay, 200y Free Relay} 2021, Conference Champion {200y Medley Relay} 2022 |
|||
| Izzy Davis | 2022 | Basketball | Details |
| All Conference, All City Tournament Team, All City 2022 | |||
| Carly deCastro | 2022 | Volleyball, Basketball | Details |
|
VOLLEYBALL: All City 2021 BASKETBALL: All City Tournament Team 2022 |
|||
| Ruby Durham | 2022 | Softball | Details |
| All City Tournament Team 2021 | |||
| Jackie Figura | 2022 | Swimming | Details |
| City Champion {200y Medley Relay, 200y Free Relay} 2021 | |||
| Mara Foley | 2022 | Cross Country, Track | Details |
|
CROSS COUNTRY: All City 2021 TRACK: Conference Champion {400M, 1600M Relay} 2021, 22; State 3 rd Place {1600M Relay} 2022 | |||
| George Gamble | 2022 | Soccer, Track | Details |
|
SOCCER: All City Tournament Team 2021 TRACK: Conference Champion {LJ, 400M Relay}, City Champion {HJ, LJ, 400M Relay, 1600M Relay}, Sectional Champion {LJ}, State Qualifier {LJ}, Indiana All Star 2022 | |||
| Alex Gantz | 2022 | Cross Country, Track | Details |
|
CROSS COUNTRY: All City 2018, 19, 20; All Conference 2019, 20, 21; All
Sectional 2019 TRACK: Sectional Champion {800M} 2019; City & Conference Champion {3200M Relay} 2021; Conference Champion {3200M Relay} 2022; Sectional & Regional Champion {3200M Relay} 2021; State Finalist {3200M Relay} 2021, 22 |
|||
| Ella Grace Giedd | 2022 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2022 | |||
| Tommy Hannon | 2022 | Football, Wrestling, Rugby | Details |
|
FOOTBALL: All Conference, All City, All State 2021 WRESTLING: City & Sectional Champion (182 lbs.), State Qualifier 2022 RUGBY: All State 2021, 22 |
|||
| Charlie Harr | 2022 | Volleyball | Details |
| All Conference, All State 2022 | |||
| Will Hasbrook | 2022 | Swimming | Details |
| City Champion {400y Free Relay} 2020, 21 | |||
| Hailee Howe | 2022 | Softball | Details |
| All City 2019, 21, 22; All City Tournament Team 2021, 22; All Conference 2021, 22 | |||
| Melanie Jansen | 2022 | Volleyball | Details |
| All City Tournament Team 2020 | |||
| Nate Joven | 2022 | Track | Details |
| City, Conference & Sectional Champion {1600M Relay} 2021, 22; City Champion {300M Hurdles} 2021; State Qualifier {1600M Relay} 2021; Conference & City Champion {400M Relay} 2022; State Qualifier (PV) 2022 | |||
| Sara Kelly | 2022 | Volleyball | Details |
| All City 2020 | |||
| Todd Kelsey | 2022 | Football | Details |
| All Conference 2021 | |||
| Dan Konvolinka | 2022 | Baseball | Details |
| All City 2021 | |||
| Madison Loiselle | 2022 | Swimming | Details |
| City Champion {100y Backstroke} 2019, 21; City Champion {200y Medley Relay, 400y Free Relay} 2021; Conference Champion {100y Backstroke} 2019 | |||
| Ruby Mason | 2022 | Soccer, Lacrosse | Details |
|
SOCCER: All City Tournament Team 2020, 21 LACROSSE: All Conference 2021; All State 2021, 22; All American 2022 |
|||
| Mary Mastrian | 2022 | Soccer | Details |
| All City Tournament Team 2020 | |||
| Nicholas Mates | 2022 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2021, 22 | |||
| Hilary Meek | 2022 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2021, 22 | |||
| Connor Moriarity | 2022 | Cross Country, Track | Details |
|
CROSS COUNTRY: All Conference, All City, All Sectional 2021 TRACK: City Champion {3200M Relay} 2021, 22; Conference & Sectional Champion {3200M Relay} 2022; State Qualifier {3200M Relay} 2022 |
|||
| Kylie Nagel | 2022 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2021, 22; All State 2022 | |||
| Mike Nash | 2022 | Soccer, Track | Details |
|
SOCCER: All Conference, All City 2021 TRACK: Conference, City & Sectional Champion {1600M Relay} 2021, 22; State Qualifier {1600M Relay} 2021 |
|||
| Danny O’Gara | 2022 | Track | Details |
| Sectional Champion {1600M Relay}2021, 22; State Qualifier {1600M Relay} 2021; Conference Champion {100M, 200M, 400M Relay} 2022; City Champion {400M Relay} 2022 | |||
| Dylan Peters | 2022 | Rugby | Details |
| All State 2022 | |||
| Tanner Quackenbush | 2022 | Football, Rugby | Details |
|
FOOTBALL: All Conference 2021 RUGBY: All State 2021, 22 |
|||
| Alex Rodriguez | 2022 | Soccer | Details |
| All Conference 2020 | |||
| A.J. Roseman | 2022 | Basketball | Details |
| Al l Conference, All City Tournament Team, All City, 2022 | |||
| Brandon Salas | 2022 | Football | Details |
| All City 2021 | |||
| Mary Bea Sowinski | 2022 | Cross Country, Track | Details |
|
CROSS COUNTRY: All City 2018, 21, All Sectional 2018, 19; All Conference 2019, 21 TRACK: City, Conference & Sectional Champion {1600M Relay} 2019; State Finalist {300M Hurdles & 1600M Relay} 2019; Conference Champion {100M Hurdles, 300M Hurdles, 1600M Relay} 2021, 22; City Champion {1600M Relay} 2022; State Qualifier {100M Hurdles} 2021, 22; State Finalist {1600M Relay} 2021; State 2 nd Place {300M Hurdles} 2021; State Finalist {300M Hurdles} 2022, State 3rd Place {1600M Relay} 2022; Indiana All Star 2022 |
|||
| Carter St. John | 2022 | Football, Basketball | Details |
|
FOOTBALL: All Conference 2020, 21; All City 2020, 21; All State 2020 BASKETBALL: All Conference 2022 |
|||
| Emma Stapleton | 2022 | Track | Details |
| City Champion {PV} 2022; City Champion {400M Relay}; Sectional Champion {LJ}; State Qualifier {400M Relay} 2022 | |||
| Mallory Stewart | 2022 | Cross Country | Details |
| All City 2021 | |||
| Mayan Stickel | 2022 | Cross Country, Track | Details |
|
CROSS COUNTRY: All Conference 2019, 20; All City 2020, 21 TRACK: Conference Champion (HJ) 2019, 21; Sectional Champion (HJ & 1600M Relay) 2019; State Finalist (HJ & 1600M Relay) 2019; Conference Champion {1600M Relay} 2021, 22; Conference Champion {800} 2022; City Champion {HJ, 400M} 2021; City Champion {800M, 1600M Relay} 2022; Sectional & Regional Champion {3200M Relay} 2021, State Finalist {3200M Relay} 2021, 22; State Finalist {1600M Relay} 2021; State 3 rd Place (1600M Relay), Indiana All Star 2022 |
|||
| Mia Todd | 2022 | Swimming | Details |
| City Champion {200y Medley Relay, 200y Free Relay} 2021 | |||
| Lily Wendt | 2022 | Softball | Details |
| All City 2021, 22; All Conference 2021, 22; All City Tournament Team 2022; North/South All Star 202; SUPERTEAM (IndyStar) 2022 | |||
| Sylvester Williams | 2022 | Track | Details |
| Conference & City Champion {400M Relay} 2022 | |||
| Michael Yurk | 2022 | Volleyball | Details |
| All Conference, All State 2021, 22 |
Class of 2023
| Name | Year | Sport(s) | Award |
|---|---|---|---|
| Caroline Bell | 2023 | Track, Basketball | Details |
|
TRACK: 2023 City Champion (400M Relay)
|
|||
| Christopher Board | 2023 | Volleyball | Details |
| 2023 All Conference, All State (IBVCA) | |||
| R.J. Bradshaw | 2023 | Track | Details |
| City Champion (110M Hurdles) 2023 | |||
| Brianna Buels | 2023 | Soccer, Track | Details |
|
SOCCER: All Conference, All City Tournament Team, All City (MCCGSA), All District (ISCA) 2019, 2020, 2022, All State (ISCA), SUPERTEAM (IndyStar), All Region (USCA) 2022 TRACK: Conference Champion {100M} 2021; Conference & City Champion and State Qualifier {400M Relay} 2022, 23; Conference Champion {1600M Relay} 2022; City Champion {200M} 2022, 23; Sectional & Regional Champion (400M Relay), State Finalist (400M Relay & 1600M Relay), Conference Champion (1600M Relay) 2023 |
|||
| Caroline Clapacs | 2023 | Cross Country, Track | Details |
|
CROSS COUNTRY: All City 2022 TRACK: Conference Champion (3200M Relay) 2022; State Finalist (3200M Relay) 2023 |
|||
| Lily Cridge | 2023 | Cross Country | Details |
|
CROSS COUNTRY: All Conference 2019; Conference Champion 2020, 21, 22; ALL CITY 2020; City Champion 2019, 21, 22; All Sectional 2019; Sectional Champion 2021, 22; All Regional 2019; Regional Champion 2021, 22; All Semi-State 2019, Semi-State Champion 2021, 22; STATE CHAMPION 2021, 22; All State 2019, 21, 22; All American 2021, 22; Gatorade Indiana Runner of the Year 2022 Conference, City, Sectional, Regional, Semi-State & STATE Champion; Gatorade Indiana Runner of the Year; All American, Female City Athlete of the Year (MCCGSA & MCAA) TRACK: Conference, Sectional & Regional Champion (3200M Relay, 3200M), City Champion (1600M, 3200M), State Finalist (3200M Relay), STATE Champion (3200M) 2021; City Champion (3200M) 2022; State Qualifier (3200M Relay) |
|||
| Robert Davidson | 2023 | Basketball | Details |
| All City Tournament Team, All City(Coaches), All Conference 2023 lbs.} 2021, 22 | |||
| William Dietrick | 2023 | Tennis | Details |
| All Conference 2021, 22; City Champion (#1 Doubles), All District(IHSTeCA) 2022 | |||
| Jack Dixon | 2023 | Wrestling | Details |
| Conference Champion (170 lbs.) 2023 | |||
| Noah Dudik | 2023 | Football, Track | Details |
|
FOOTBALL: All Conference 2022 TRACK: Conference Champion (400M), Conference, City & Sectional Champion (1600M Relay) 2022; Conference & City Champion (1600M Relay), City Champion (400M), State Qualifier (1600M Relay) 2023 |
|||
| Aiden Duncan | 2023 | Baseball, Football | Details |
|
BASEBALL: All City 2021, 22, 23; All Conference 2023 FOOTBALL: All Conference 2022, State Mental Attitude Award Winner |
|||
| Davis Falcon | 2023 | Cross Country, Track | Details |
|
CROSS COUNTRY: All City 2021, 22; All Conference & All Sectional 2022 TRACK: Conference, City & Sectional Champion (3200M Relay), State Qualifier (3200M Relay) 2022; City Champion (1600M), Sectional & Regional Champion (3200M Relay), State Qualifier (3200M Relay) 2023 |
|||
| Grace Felts | 2023 | Volleyball, Track | Details |
|
VOLLEYBALL: All City (MCCGSA), All City Tournament Team 2022 TRACK: Conference Champion (300M Hurdles, 1600M Relay), City Champion (1600M Relay), State Finalist (1600M Relay) 2023 | |||
| Isaac Fischer | 2023 | Football | Details |
| All Conference, All City(Coaches), All State (IFCA) 2022 | |||
| Benjamin Harless | 2023 | Soccer | Details |
| All Conference, All City (Coaches) 2022 | |||
| Grace Hurley | 2023 | Swimming/Diving | Details |
| Conference Champion (Diving) 2020, 21, 22, 23; Sectional Diving Champion: 2023; State Finalist 2020, 23; City Champion (Diving) 2020, 21, 22; State Finalist (10th place) 2021; State Finalist (7th place) 2022 | |||
| Zade Kalesperis | 2023 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2021, 22; All State (IHSLA) 2023 | |||
| CeCe Leffler | 2023 | Soccer | Details |
| All Conference, All City (MCCGSA) 2022 | |||
| Aaron Loiselle | 2023 | Swimming, Cross Country | Details |
|
SWIMMING: Conference Champion (200y IM) 2020, 21; City Champion {100y Fly, 400y Free Relay} 2020; City Champion (200y Medley Relay, 400y Free Relay) 2021, 22; City Champion (200y IM); Conference Champion (200y Medley Relay) 2022 CROSS COUNTRY: All City 2022 |
|||
| Wade McAllister | 2023 | Football, Lacrosse | Details |
|
FOOTBALL: All Conference 2022 LACROSSE: All State (IHSLA) 2023 |
|||
| Nathan Meyer | 2023 | Rugby | Details |
| All State (RI) 2023 | |||
| Jakob Moore | 2023 | Rugby | Details |
| All State (RI) 2023 | |||
| Jack Murray | 2023 | Baseball | Details |
| All City (coaches) 2022 | |||
| Avery Nagel | 2023 | Softball | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA), All Conference 2023 | |||
| Billy Nash | 2023 | Lacrosse | Details |
| All Conference 2023 | |||
| J.P. Polackin | 2023 | Baseball | Details |
| All City (coaches) 2022, 23, All Conference 2022, 23 | |||
| William Pruitt | 2023 | Golf, Tennis | Details |
|
GOLF: All City, All Conference 2021, 22; City Champion 2023; All Sectional 2022; Sectional Champion 2023; All Regional 2023; State Finalist 2022, 23; All State 2023 TENNIS: All Conference 2021, 22; City Champion {#1 Doubles}, All District(IHSTeCA) 2022 |
|||
| Lucy Pyrz | 2023 | Softball | Details |
| All City Tournament Team 2021; All City (MCCGSA), All Conference 2023 | |||
| John Rushenberg | 2023 | Wrestling | Details |
| City Champion (160 lbs.) 2021, 22 & Sectional Champion (160 lbs.) 2022, 2023 | |||
| Maggie Ryan | 2023 | Soccer | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA) 2020 | |||
| Chloe Schmitz | 2023 | Soccer | Details |
| All City Tournament Team 2021 | |||
| Stella Schulte | 2023 | Softball | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA), All Conference 2023 | |||
| Sarah Semon | 2023 | Golf | Details |
| All City | |||
| Lauren Shanks | 2023 | Volleyball | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA), All District(IHSVCA) 2022 | |||
| Lexi Thatcher | 2023 | Volleyball | Details |
| All City (MCCGSA) 2021, 22; All District(IHSVCA) 2022 | |||
| Anna Thompson | 2023 | Track, Basketball | Details |
|
TRACK: Conference & City Champion (Discus) 2022, 23; Sectional Champion (Discus) 2023 BASKETBALL: All Conference & All City (MCCGSA) 2023 |
|||
| Drew VanVleet | 2023 | Football | Details |
| All Conference, All City(Coaches), All State (IFCA), SUPERTEAM 2022 | |||
| Jef Waugh | 2023 | Wrestling, Football | Details |
|
WRESTLING: City Champion 2022, Sectional & Regional Champion (195 lbs.) 2023 FOOTBALL: All Conference 2022 |
|||
| Cole Weber | 2023 | Track, Soccer | Details |
|
SOCCER: All City (Coaches) 2022 TRACK: Conference Champion (1600M Relay), Sectional & Regional Champion (3200M Relay), State Qualifier (1600M Relay & 3200M Relay) 2023 |
Return to Top